|
Cheltenham, 48-hour decs, Ten To Follow, the Breeders' Cup............don't miss TURFBLOG
WELCOME TO RACELINE
THE column is split into several sections:
TIP OF THE DAY (online by 11 am), giving a selection for every day's racing, plus more for the big meetings.
SIX FOR THE WEEKEND (updated every Friday night or Saturday morning), giving six selections for the weekend’s racing.
UPPING THE ANTE (updated every week), giving exclusive ante-post advice for forthcoming big races.
FOR THE NOTEBOOK (updated regularly), giving a list of horses to have caught the eye and worth following.
TURFBLOG: THE THOUGHTS OF A RACING FANATIC (updated most days), giving an informal, chatty, personalised take on the world of racing.
FEEDBACK -- if you have any comments on this column or racing topics in general, e-mail richard.silverwood@sky.com
.
TIP OF THE DAY
Saturday November 21 SCHINDLERS HUNT Ascot 3.10 WIN He’s better on decent ground, so let’s hope the forecast rain doesn’t get in too much. But this revamped Amlin Chase presents the perfect opportunity for Dessie Hughes’s classy nine-year-old to bag the big prize his consistency deserves. He ran blinders at both the Cheltenham and Aintree Festivals last spring, finding 2m5f a shade too far in the Ryanair Chase and then blundering away certain victory at the last two fences in the Melling Chase. This 2m3f trip is ideal and he has a fitness and weight advantage over his old rival, VOY POR USTEDES, who may need the run.
FRIDAY: VINO GRIEGO UNPLACED THURSDAY: MOUNT HELICON 3RD WEDNESDAY: SYNCHRONISED WON 7/4 TUESDAY: AEGEAN DAWN WON MONDAY: SPRING JIM WON SUNDAY: LIDAR 2ND SATURDAY: LIE FORRIT WON 11/4 FRIDAY: TITO BUSTILLO UNPLACED THURSDAY: PHIDIPPIDES WON 5/2 WEDNESDAY: MASSASOIT 2ND TUESDAY: INCHIDALY ROCK WON
SIX FOR THE WEEKEND
SATURDAY/SUNDAY NOVEMBER 21/22:
ASTURIENNE Saturday Huntingdon 12.05 WIN
PEPE SIMO Saturday Haydock 12.15 WIN
MASTER MEDIC Saturday Ascot 2.05 WIN
BURTON PORT Saturday Haydock 2.20 EACH/WAY
KARABAK Saturday Ascot 2.35 WIN
ANY THE WISER Saturday Ascot 3.45 WIN
LAST WEEKEND'S SELECTIONS INCLUDED FOUR WINNERS (Sullumo, Dunguib, The Biscuit Club and Tataniano)
UPPING THE ANTE
RECENT BIG-RACE WINNERS INCLUDE:
DARLEY SUN 9/2 (advised at 18/1 and 14/1 for the Totesport Cesarewitch, up to TEN WEEKS before the race) GENKI 14/1 (advised at 16/1 for the Stewards' Cup at Goodwood) CONDUIT (advised at 9/2 for the King George at Ascot)
This week's ante-post advice (given on Tuesday November 17):
Seasons Holidays Champion Chase (Cheltenham, Wednesday March 18): BIG ZEB 5/1 (Ladbrokes) WIN
FOR THE NOTEBOOK
WINNERS FROM PREVIOUS LISTS INCLUDE: DISTINCTIVE 33/1, MORANA 9/1, OPINION POLL 15/2, SIYOUNI 7/1, BLUE JACK 6/1, HIGH STANDING 6/1 and 5/2, BUZZWORD 11/2, NIDEEB 11/2, ELUSIVE AWARD 9/2, DARLEY SUN 9/2, AWZAAN 4/1, GOLDEN DESERT 4/1, MAWATHEEQ 7/2, CORPORAL MADDOX 7/2, PLUM SUGAR 7/2, SECRET SOCIETY 10/3, RAINBOW PEAK 3/1, BORDER PATROL 3/1, AWZAAN 11/4, DYNA WALTZ 11/4, BOUNTY BOX 11/4, LADY OF THE DESERT 5/2, KINGSFORT 9/4, SHAMANDAR 9/4, QUARREL 2/1, MUFARRH 2/1, PAISLEY 15/8, CANFORD CLIFFS 7/4, LAYLA'S HERO 13/8, CONDUIT 13/8, CRITICAL MOMENT 6/4, NOLL WALLOP 6/4, ARCTIC 11/8, POET'S VOICE 11/8, HARLESTONE SNAKE 11/8, AVE 5/4, AMEER 6/5, STRAWBERRYDAIQUIRI 6/5, CHINESE WHITE 11/10 and many more.
LATEST LIST UPDATED: TUESDAY NOVEMBER 10 NEXT UPDATE: TUESDAY DECEMBER 1
FLAT
FIELD DAY (WON, Newmarket October 31)
This time last year, trainer Brian Meehan went into hibernation dreaming of Classic success with the likes of CROWDED HOUSE and DELEGATOR. The dreams all turned spectacularly sour but that didn’t stop his assistant enthusing about the prospects of this two-year-old daughter of Cape Cross after a splendid debut victory in a maiden Meehan has now won three times in the last five seasons. The enthusiasm is not misplaced either, judging by the way the filly travelled strongly throughout and picked up to leave behind a John Gosden rival who’d had the benefit of a run and a Sir Michael Stoute favourite. “She could be something special next year,” was the verdict of the yard.
HAMLOOLA (3RD, Doncaster November 7)
End-of-season maidens are decried by many. But they are the source of many a winner for the following spring and this season, they continued to fascinate right up to the final day of the campaign. By all accounts, William Haggas’s Hamdan Al Maktoum-owned daughter of Red Ransom is only a small, plain filly, who drifted markedly ahead of her debut here. And she duly spent most of the race in rear, looking very inexperienced. But she made relentless progress through the final 2f and I have little doubt that she might have won if Richard Hills had been a bit harder on her. Providing she trains on, his kindness will be repaid, though, in 2010 when she could develop into a nice handicapper over trips of 1m-10f.
HYMNSHEET (WON, Yarmouth October 20)
Quite a decent juvenile maiden containing several choicely-bred fillies from big yards and throwing up the unusual sight of a debutant winner from the Sir Michael Stoute yard, suggesting a horse with a future. After being held up in rear, her progress wasn’t spectacular but it was persistent and she pleased with the way she wore down a rival who’d had previous experience. A daughter of Pivotal, she’s also a half-sister to Chorist, who won the Group One Pretty Polly Stakes in Ireland for the same owners, the Cheveley Park Stud. “She’s a nice filly, bred to improve, and Ryan (Moore) was impressed,” said Chris Richardson, Cheveley Park’s spokesman.
JAN VERMEER (WON, Saint-Cloud November 1)
It is not the purpose of this column to point you in the direction of ST NICHOLAS ABBEY. You’ve probably got there already, thanks to his amazing Racing Post Trophy success. But amid all the understandable hype surrounding the potential, new ‘wonder horse’, it would be unwise to forget this fast-improving stablemate, who looks sure to give any horse a run for his money in the middle-distance Classics next season. On jockey-bookings, he was the second string for this Group One Criterium International over 1m and when he set off in front, it was assumed that his role was to ensure a true gallop. He did just that but, as it happened, he never stopped, kicking clear once they‘d straightened up for home and relishing the stamina-test provided by the Soft ground. A son of Montjeu out of Pennekamp mare, he is superbly bred.
LAAHEB (WON, Newmarket October 31)
After fracturing a pastern as a two-year-old, Michael Jarvis’s enticingly-bred son of Cape Cross, out of a Sadler’s Wells mare, is making up for lost time with a vengeance. And on the evidence of this victory in a good tight-knit renewal of the Listed James Seymour Stakes, he can progress into a Group performer next season. He had the lowest official rating of all five runners and 11lbs to find with the in-form Godolphin favourite. What’s more, he was asked to adopt new, restrained tactics after bolting up to make all last time. But no bother. He ran out a cosy winner and considering he hails from the family of Warrsan and Needle Gun, he is a banker to improve further with age.
MODEYRA (WON, Doncaster October 23)
Any two-year-old filly who is a daughter of Shamardal, who won the French 1,000 Guineas, and Zahrat Dubai, who won the Nassau Stakes and was third in the Oaks, is worth a second glance. But it’s a fair bet that Godolphin’s charge will be receiving more than glances when she takes to the big stage in 2010. In a warm, competitive maiden for her debut, she was handed a tricky, wide draw but broke smartly, travelled sweetly and picked up to order without Frankie Dettori having to get at all serious. Apparently a lovely, scopy type, she is almost certainly Group class.
PADMINI (WON, Lingfield October 29)
German Group One winner Tiger Hill is making a name for himself as a sire and was responsible for another nice winner in this Godolphin debutant, out of an Unfuwain mare, Petrushka, who won the Irish Oaks. Considering she’s so stoutly bred (and even a half-sister to a hurdler), she did well to win over such a sharp 7f, especially as she’s a big, leggy sort and especially as the more experienced Richard Hannon runner-up pinched two or three lengths in front, approaching the final couple of furlongs. Not until the final furlong did this filly truly get going but when she did, she smoothly reeled in the leader and looks a certainty to improve over longer distances next term.
PIPETTE (3RD Newbury October 24)
Owner George Strawbridge had his share of success at the Breeders’ Cup and might enjoy more back in the UK next year with this interesting daughter of Pivotal out of a Sadler’s Wells mare. The form of her maiden victory on debut is working out well and she handled this step-up in class, in a good, competitive Listed Radley Stakes, despite giving the impression that she badly needs much further than the 7f trip. Stoked up a good 2f out, she came under heavy pressure but kept finding and ended up running on very strongly. With normal improvement, she should make her mark in Group contests next term for trainer Andrew Balding.
RADIO WAVE (3RD, Yarmouth October 20)
It’s a long way from a Yarmouth maiden to the Oaks at Epsom but it wouldn’t surprise me if John Gosden has the route plotted for this very well-bred daughter of Arc hero Dalakhani and Ebor winner Tuning. Quite clearly, she’s bred for middle distances and that’s the way she ran on this debut in a decent maiden, the winner of which (HYMNSHEET) we have already mentioned. Niggled and ridden from some way out, she then struggled to find room as the pace quickened before keeping on nicely for pushed hands-and-heels in the final furlong. She is sure to have learned a lot from the experience and it is to be hoped that she can lose her maiden tag before being aimed at an Oaks trial in the spring.
SECRECY (WON, Newmarket October 31)
This wasn’t a particularly strong handicap and I had mixed feelings about the heavy support for Godolphin’s three-year-old favourite, considering he’d disappointed on his previous run, failing to confirm the promise he’d shown on his belated seasonal bow at Doncaster’s St Leger meeting. But lapping up the give in the ground, as most King’s Best progeny do, he made a mockery of his not inconsiderable mark of 102 and as a lightly-raced sort, he could develop into a serious Pattern performer next season. After travelling very smoothly, the only danger he encountered was traffic. Once in the clear, he quickened appreciably to give Frankie Dettori an armchair ride.
TAMAATHUL (WON, Doncaster October 23)
Even allowing for the fact that Barry Hills’s Hamdan Al Maktoum-owned two-year-old grey had the benefit of a valuable previous run, this was a most taking pillar-to-post triumph that spreadeagled a fair-looking maiden field. He broke from the gates like a sprinter and jockey Tadhg O’Shea just let him bowl, which the colt did most enthusiastically. A son of Tiger Hill, he did hit the ground quite hard, suggesting he might not appreciate a quick surface -- a view reinforced by his pedigree, which shows that the dam is by Linamix. But he has the scope to develop into a solid miler in 2010.
TIMEPIECE (WON, Newmarket October 31)
There are few better records in racing than Henry Cecil’s Oaks roll of honour and he has almost certainly found another contender for Epsom on the first Friday in June with this daughter of Zamindar. A richly competitive renewal of the Listed Montrose Stakes represented another step-up in class for her and gave her a huge amount to find on official ratings. But she not only took it in her stride, she also surprised even the master of Warren Place himself, who said: “I promise you haven’t seen the best of this filly yet. She didn’t like the (Softish) ground and had gone over the top.” He should know -- because she is a half-sister to the Cecil duo Father Time and Passage Of Time and the second dam is a half-sister to his Group One winner and Oaks runner-up, All At Sea. It is also highly significant that, on debut, Cecil pitched her into a maiden that he had taken previously with one of his Oaks winners, Light Shift, and with another of his Oaks runners-up, Breeders’ Cup heroine Midday.
JUMPS
ALEGRALIL (WON, Towcester November 5)
Donald McCain’s talented hurdling mare, WHITEOAK, appears to have temporarily lost her way since emerging as a Champion Hurdle outsider last season. But the yard are not unduly worried, partly because they believe this four-year-old daughter of King’s Theatre is capable of becoming even better. She certainly provided the fireworks on this Guy Fawkes Day re-appearance. Although her early jumping was a bit awkward and novicey, she was much tidier once sent to the front from halfway and hardly had to be shaken up to draw a long clear up the home straight. Sizeable and scopy, she’s a half-sister to a 3m chaser and, intriguingly, the dam is related to the great Dublin Flyer.
ANY THE WISER (WON, Uttoxeter October 30)
The Waley-Cohen family have National Hunt blood coursing through their veins and, on the evidence of his Bumper debut here, they can look ahead to many enjoyable days with this rangy-looking, five-year-old son of Kahyasi. Time will tell how strong the race was but he could hardly have won it more impressively, arriving on the scene tanking along on the bridle before quickening to the front and powering home. He’s a half-brother to several winning jumpers in France and it would be no surprise to see him transferred to the professional care of Nicky Henderson in due course.
BIG ZEB (WON, Navan November 8)
If, like me, you feel that champion chaser MASTER MINDED was not at his best last season and could be vulnerable this time round, you will be desperately searching for a challenger to lower his colours. Or at least to give him a proper test come the Cheltenham Festival next March. Look no further than Colm Murphy’s son of Oscar, who faces a make-or-break campaign that will surely banish his well-documented jumping problems and win him the major prize his supreme talent deserves. The eight-year-old came to grief in both his prep race and in the Queen Mother itself last term before running Paul Nicholls’s title-holder to a head at Punchestown. But he could not have jumped, or travelled, better on this sparkling seasonal bow and in toying with his rivals, Barry Geraghty did not even have to ask him to come out of first gear. It was an incredibly snug victory, especially as he was giving weight away on Heavy ground that his trainer insists he doesn’t function too well on! Please, please snap up the very generous 8/1 on offer for the Festival. This is a serious racehorse who was runner-up to the likes of Captain Cee Bee and Clopf in Bumpers and to Sizing Europe and Catch Me over hurdles.
BOBBY EWING (WON, Uttoxeter October 20)
This is often one of the better early-season novice hurdles. Indeed it was won last year by the hugely promising David Pipe charge, GREAT ENDEAVOUR. Another competitive renewal was turned into a one-horse procession by Nigel Twiston-Davies’s once-raced Irish point winner, a four-year-old son of Bob’s Return. He could not have been more impressive on his timber debut, coasting into contention entering the home straight and sauntering clear, hard held. A half-brother to several winners, he was bought by the shrewd Anthony Bromley for the incredibly lucky ownership syndicate, the Million In Mind partnership, and looks certain to bring them more success.
DOOR BOY (WON, Aintree October 25)
Howard Johnson’s Graham Wylie-owned six-year-old lost his way last season after chasing home the classy DIAMOND HARRY at Cheltenham’s Open meeting. But he was bought -- for the princely sum of £185,000 -- primarily for fences and went some way towards proving that on this triumphant seasonal bow. He travelled strongly throughout and did well to recover from a shocking error -- his only of the race -- when ploughing through the cross-fence. A well-built son of the under-rated sire jumps Dr Massini, he has the raw talent to progress into a good horse.
GATES OF ROME (2ND, Punchestown October 27)
Hard to say how strong this maiden hurdle was but I was quite taken by the timber debut of Colm Murphy’s five-year-old, who arrived on the scene full of running as the front two kicked clear. He didn’t quite pull out as much as looked likely but might still have won but for an awkward leap at the last when landing on all fours. He was outstayed only by a winner with a fitness and experience advantage and looks sure to go one better soon. Owned by the Gigginstown House Stud, he won a 3m point in April and is very much bred for the jumping game.
IN COMPLIANCE (WON, Thurles November 5)
On all known ratings and form, Dessie Hughes’s new recruit had a huge amount in hand for this Listed chase. But he still deserves credit for a polished performance after a mammoth 679-day absence from the track with a muscle injury and it might yet be worth remembering that he was once touted as a Gold Cup horse by his previous handler, Michael O’Brien, especially after beating the then holder of the Cheltenham crown, War Of Attrition, in December 2006. Indeed O’Brien always reckoned he was superior to Forget The Past, who was third for him in the Blue Riband. Quite how much ability he retains we will find out in the coming months but he bounced round here, jumping for fun. His chief asset has always appeared to be his pace but he is bred to stay 3m, although he’s never won over the trip, and another plus is that he‘s still lightly-raced for a nine-year-old chaser (this was only the 15th start of his career).
KILLULTAGH QUEEN (WON, Fairyhouse November 4)
Bumper king Willie Mullins says he’s had a few decent mares by King’s Theatre in his time. Well, he definitely has another in this five-year-old who made mincemeat of her rivals on debut. Unlike many National Hunt Flat horses from the yard, who make all, she settled into a rhythm in mid-division and as she made progress, it mattered not a jot that she had to come wide into the home straight. Indeed jockey Patrick Mullins didn’t even ask a question of her until as late as the final 2f when she cruised alongside the front two and then, shaken up at the 1f pole, she quickened clear. It was a classy effort and it will be fascinating to see if Mullins stays on the level with her or switches to hurdles.
KNOCKARA BEAU (WON, Carlisle November 1)
Flying the flag for the small Northern yard of George Charlton is this thoroughly likeable, scopy six-year-old who progressed with every run over hurdles last season and even finished only ten lengths behind the redoubtable MIKAEL D’HAGUENET when fifth in the Ballymore Properties at the Cheltenham Festival. He’s always been considered a chaser in the making, though, and underlined that he has a big future with this exciting seasonal bow in a hot race. OK, he was receiving fully 16lbs from the favourite, but he was far less experienced over the bigger obstacles, although judging by the impeccable way he travelled and jumped, you would never have guessed it. The fact that he hails from an unfashionable stable means he is always likely to be under-estimated but I will be amazed if he doesn’t plunder some major prizes in the years to come, especially as he acts on any ground.
LITTLE JOSH (2ND, Aintree October 25)
Given that we have already named the winner of this novices‘ chase, DOOR BOY, it would be remiss not to include Nigel Twiston-Davies’s promising runner-up too. For he did nothing wrong, jumping beautifully in front and looking sure to prevail until either blowing up or simply getting outspeeded at the business end. A rangy, lightly-raced seven-year-old, he is making quiet but pleasing progress and looks sure to win plenty of races, particularly when stepped up to 3m. Don’t be surprised to see him pop up at Cheltenham’s Open meeting or Newbury’s Hennessy meeting next.
MASTER MEDIC (WON, Ascot October 31)
I was disappointed to note that connections have opted to bypass the Paddy Power Gold Cup with this talented eight-year-old chaser because on the evidence of this seasonal re-appearance, he must have gone close, even allowing for a steep rise in the weights. Despite a long, injury-enforced absence, he took the eye in the paddock and did extremely well to reel in the long-time leader after looking in trouble on emerging from Swinley Bottom. A return to 2m4f will suit, and he looks the kind of quality horse his owners, Pell-Mell Partners, have been waiting for to follow in the footsteps of big names like Queen Mother Champion Chase winner Katabatic and Hennessy Gold Cup winner Cogent.
MONASTRELL (WON, Down Royal November 7)
Given that the strongly fancied favourite had chased home smart novice hurdler LUSKA LAD on his debut, this has to go down as a very useful Bumper debut by Noel Meade’s four-year-old son of Terimon. I suspect the steady pace was in his favour, turning the race into a test of speed, rather than stamina, but the ground was plenty testing enough and there could be no quibbling about the way he travelled, eased into contention and quickened effortlessly clear under the familiar sight of a motionless Nina Carberry. He’s a very interesting prospect for novice hurdles for the rest of the season.
MEGASTAR (WON, Sandown November 7)
If it’s true that this nicely-bred son of crack jumps sire Kayf Tara has worked well at home with classy stayer Mourilyan, it is hardly surprising that trainer Gary Moore rates him his best Bumper horse. He duly translated homework to the track in what is invariably a warm, informative race. The highly-regarded Nicky Henderson favourite looked sure to win when going on after travelling beautifully. But no sooner had he hit the front than Moore’s charge swamped him on the outer with a serious turn of foot. The trainer says he has a big engine and is built to jump obstacles. For once, an ambitious name might well be justified!
PRIDE OF DULCOTE (WON, Worcester October 21)
Paul Nicholls’s six-year-old took high rank in staying novice hurdles last season and ended up on a lofty rating of 147 after getting pipped by a whisker at the Cheltenham Festival. He had only one serious rival to worry about for this chasing debut but could hardly have been more impressive in making all. Although he’s blessed with stamina, there’s bags of speed in his locker too and the way he travelled characterised the display. He also jumped brilliantly, measuring every fence perfectly, and even at this stage of the season, it’s not hard to envisage him contesting the Sun Alliance at next year’s Festival -- especially as Nicholls revealed that he “was not fully wound up and will improve for the outing”.
PEPE SIMO (WON, Wincanton November 7)
So remorselessly do the Irish dominate the Champion bumper at the Cheltenham Festival that fewer and fewer home-trained animals appear good enough to take up the challenge. So it is perhaps significant that this five-year-old was pitched into the race by Paul Nicholls -- and he acquitted himself well too, finishing ninth. The good impression has been carried over to hurdles this autumn with a hard-fought victory on debut being followed by a smooth and classy follow-up under a penalty here. He has his quirks and cannot hit the front too soon but when allowed to travel off a decent pace and unleash his turn of foot, he is a potent force, capable of mixing it with the best in novice company.
PESOTO (WON, Limerick November 9)
Edward O’Grady’s grey French import is quietly tipped to make an impact over fences this term -- and we found out why with this fluent pillar-to-post victory. It probably wasn’t much of a race but the second and third had the benefit of previous action this term and he ran them ragged, jumping with terrific aplomb. After two breathing operations during the summer, the six-year-old is expected to improve considerably on the two chase outings he had last term, in which case a big prize is heading his way. Because on debut, he finished only half a length behind the very smart JONCOL and next time out, he was plunged into a Grade One, finishing sixth behind the likes of TATENEN and COOLDINE.
SHILLINGSTONE (WON, Kempton November 2)
Now here’s a barmy, long-range tip for you. The Alners’ lightly-raced seven-year-old to win the Fulke Walwyn/Kim Muir for amateur riders at next year’s Cheltenham Festival. Outrageous maybe but one can already begin to see the seedlings of the plot being sown by the yard, who have targeted the race many times before. As a graduate from the pointing and hunting fields, the horse is an honest, old-fashioned stayer, who proved the perfect conveyance here for amateur Sam Allwood, claiming 7lbs. Rated only 115, he has a fair way to shoot up the handicap before he can be considered for Cheltenham but the manner in which he won suggests there’s much more mileage in the tank.
THE TOTHER ONE (2ND, Wincanton November 7)
Paul Nicholls’s eight-year-old son of Accordion was so useful as a long-distance novice hurdler two seasons ago that he finished third at both the Cheltenham and Aintree Festivals. He suffered a minor injury when coming to grief on only his second start over fences a year ago but this highly encouraging return, off what looked a stiffish mark of 146 and in a competitive handicap, suggests he still very much has a future -- maybe even as leading contender for the Hennessy Gold Cup at Newbury at the end of November. His rustiness and inexperience caused some sketchy jumping in rear early on but he emerged from the pack as the only danger to the all-the-way winner, running on strongly, despite never looking likely to get there. Nicholls warns he’s not the scopiest of horses but he is blessed with huge talent, not to mention untapped potential.
VOLER LA VEDETTE (WON, Down Royal November 6)
And so we save the best till last because there’s no doubt in my mind about the most exhilarating performance of the jumps season so far. And that was this electric victory in a warm Grade Three by Colm Murphy’s rapidly improving five-year-old mare. Her re-appearance win had been impressive enough but she took this step-up in class without turning a hair, leaving in her wake the likes of GO NATIVE, one of last season’s leading novices. She jumped athletically throughout and took off approaching the last, which she pinged, to scorch clear in a display that had some observers whispering Champion Hurdle. It certainly brought back memories of another super mare in Murphy’s care, Feathard Lady, who also took this prize en route to Grade One spoils. This one is described by the handler as “a proper filly” and, sensibly, he has earmarked the David Nicholson as her Festival target.
TURFBLOG: The Thoughts Of A Racing Fanatic
FRIDAY NOVEMBER 20
Amid the tiresome Flat racing v Jumps racing debate, propagated by the ‘Racing Post’, at the whim of Alastair Down, one of the leading arguments is that the National Hunt game is more progressive, more enlightened, more in tune with what the public want.
Yesterday that was exposed as a myth, if not a downright lie.
The ‘Post’, bless its cotton socks, ran a piece on the prospect of 48-hour declarations for Jumps racing, which included the views of several top trainers.
Rarely have I read a collection of such self-serving, blinkered opinions, completely oblivious of the good the move would bestow on punters.
Nicky Henderson, Philip Hobbs, Nigel Twiston-Davies, Charlie Mann, you name them. All lined up to condemn the proposal with illogical, short-sighted arguments that revolved entirely around their own personal inconveniences. To hell with racing as a whole.
To balance the piece, the ‘Post’ also trotted out the views of local evening newspapers, who underlined how crazy it is during the winter that in their Friday editions, for instance, they are able to publish, by deadline, the final decs for Saturday’s Flat all-weather cards but not the jumps cards. Frustrated readers bombard their offices with complaints. The papers, quite rightly, blame the racing authorities for being unable to release the runners and riders to them in time.
How can racing possible benefit from such an anomaly? Quite simply, if punters cannot access the runners, their enthusiasm will wane. I accept that, in this day and age of rapidly evolving media technology, the public do not rely only on their evening papers for racing information. But as I said in this blog a few days ago, it is an irresistible fact that the longer the final declarations for any race, any meeting are in the public domain (via whatever platform), the greater the potential for stimulating interest among punters, either through having a bet, actually going to the meeting or simply having a chat down the pub, over the phone or on an online forum.
Of course, as the jumps trainers pointed out, we run the risk of an increased number of non-runners. But invariably, that is caused by late going-changes because of the weather. And given the sheer unpredictability of the weather in this country, there is just as much possibility of that happening on the night before a race or even on the morning of a race as there is 48 hours in advance.
I have spoken to Nick Attenborough, the new PR director for the Racing For Change initiative, about this and I know he is strongly in favour of bringing the Jumps into line with the Flat on 48-hour decs. I wish him well in the onerous task of persuading our stick-in-the-mud training brigade.
THURSDAY NOVEMBER 19
I read in the ‘Racing Post’ the other day observations from a reader about the deteriorating state of some of the facilities and stands at Cheltenham.
I agree. They’re stuck in the 80s and 90s. It can’t be long now before a major facelift is announced.
I suspect that many punters and professionals are resigned to the same but daren’t speak out too loudly in case the facelift they get is a monstrosity of Ascot proportions.
Whenever it happens, the task of coming up with a plan that suits all and protects the hallowed venue of the greatest sporting Festival on earth is going to be a monumental one.
TUESDAY NOVEMBER 17
Was it me imagining things amid a series of losers or was the buzz missing from Cheltenham’s Open meeting last weekend?
Maybe it was because the weather was so bad. Maybe it was because crowds were down (haven’t read that in the ‘Racing Post’….oh no, silly me, of course not, it’s jumps racing). Maybe it’s because the Irish raiding party wasn’t as strong as in previous years. Maybe it was the recession. But something was definitely lacking.
Yes, the victory of WELL CHIEF helped to raise the spirits and pump up the atmosphere on Sunday. But there’s no doubt that the quality and strength of depth of the cards was not what we have come to expect from the Open.
The turnout for two of the three novice chases was desperate and too many of the handicaps were ordinary. I can’t remember Paddy Power Gold Cup day serving up worse fare than Saturday’s card and I am beginning to despair about how much longer we must endure the wildly uncompetitive cross-country dross.
I know I have a bee in my bonnet about six-race cards. But this was another example of how they fail to provide true value for money, unless they are enriched from top to bottom. As things stand in the British racing calendar, only the Cheltenham Festival itself and Royal Ascot are blessed with sufficient quality to get away with just six races per day.
SATURDAY NOVEMBER 14
LIVE from Cheltenham! Not for the first time, the forecasters got it wrong. The weather was not as bad as predicted yesterday. The serious rain did not arrive until about 4 pm and although it then persisted up to about midnight, I wouldn't expect today's ground to be worse than Soft. The worst of the weather today is expected to be raging winds, getting stronger as the day goes on.
Good luck!
THURSDAY NOVEMBER 12
Every year I promise myself not to get involved with the Tote Ten To Follow competition for the jumps season.
It’s not that I don’t like the competition. It’s fantastic. It’s just that failure, barring an unfeasible amount of luck, which you need to win it, depresses me beyond belief! I also reckon the competition affects your betting judgement during the season in that you tend to remain too loyal to the horses in your lists.
However every year I succumb. Last year, it was as late as ten minutes to 12 midday on the first day of the Open meeting when I rang my lists through on my mobile amid a cacophony of noise in O’Neill’s pub at Montpellier in Cheltenham!
The truth of the matter is that the competition is irresistible. So I have burned the midnight oil this week trying to produce the names of ten horses that could change my life!
I am peeved and stunned that two of Ireland’s most promising jumpers, VOLER LA VEDETTE and TREACLE, are not even available to be chosen. But as I write, miraculously, I have whittled down my choices to these 16 animals……
BIG BUCK’S, BIG ZEB, CASEY JONES, COOLDINE, DUNGUIB, HURRICANE FLY, KAUTO STAR, KILLYGLEN, KNOCKARA BEAU, MASTER MEDIC, NOTRE PERE, SHINING GALE, SOLWHIT, TAROTINO, THE TOTHER ONE and ZAYNAR.
Now how many lists do I need to accommodate all options?……..Aaaargh!
TUESDAY NOVEMBER 10
In Friday’s blog, I touched on the “wonderful” coverage of the Breeders’ Cup by the US TV networks. So it was pleasing to read in yesterday’s ‘Racing Post’ confirmation of my view from columnist Rodney Masters.
I quote……”A US television sports producer must have noted that President Obama’s speeches are refreshingly unobstructed by soundbites and verbosity. ESPN’s coverage of the Breeders’ Cup adopted a similar strategy, and it created the perfect blend for the racing regular and non-specialist viewer, a delicate balance.
“A thoroughly professional presentation, with an array of novel and easy-to-understand graphics, their Santa Anita team was enhanced by our own Nick Luck.
“He skilfully filled in snippets of information for the US audience in the European challenge, including a precis of the Fallon story and the Conduit death threat……..”
I couldn’t have put it better myself. I wonder if Matt Chapman, of At The Races, took note. Or are we lumbered with his irrational, immature ejaculations and outrageous criticisms and exaggerations for ever more?
MONDAY NOVEMBER 9
So there goes another Flat season riding off into the sunset.
An excellent one too, in my view. Watching the breathtaking performance by ZENYATTA in the final race at Santa Anita on Saturday night, only one regret crossed my mind. SEA THE STARS really should have been there.
With Cheltenham‘s superb Open meeting on the horizon, it won‘t take long to switch fully into jumps mode. In fact, I’ve just received the track’s pre-meeting magazine, which they send out every year to members. Talk about whetting the appetite!
SUNDAY NOVEMBER 8
Watching Johnny Murtagh floundering on LILLIE LANGTRY at the Breeders’ Cup on Friday night saved me lots of money yesterday.
For I was suddenly hit by vivid flashbacks from last year when Murtagh encountered all sorts of problems at the same Santa Anita track on fancied mounts from the Aidan O’Brien yard.
Those problems surfaced again on an awful second day for Ballydoyle when, incredibly, not one of their five top-notch runners was even placed. So I was relieved to have kept my ALFRED NOBEL, VISCOUNT NELSON and RIP VAN WINKLE money in my pocket.
Why is it that O’Brien horses do not seem to be suited to American racing? Many question their ability to hit the gates running. But question marks must surely be hovering over Murtagh now.
Argue all you like about the reasons for Ballydoyle’s record at the Breeders’ Cup. But the statistics don’t lie. O’Brien has saddled only four winners from 59 runners, while Murtagh has ridden three winners from 26 rides and only one for O‘Brien. By the time next year’s event comes round, Murtagh will have booted home only one winner in ten years -- and that was MAN OF IRON in the uncompetitive Marathon on Friday night, which ended a barren spell for the yard of six years and 28 runners. With the quality of ammunition Team Ballydoyle have had to fire, it is a record that bears no resemblance to their magnificent performances in the UK, Ireland and the rest of Europe.
It all came to a head in the Breeders‘ Cup Dirt Mile last night with the defeat of hot favourite MASTERCRAFTSMAN in a weak renewal -- thanks largely to Murtagh failing hopelessly to keep the colt balanced as he made his challenge on the rail.
Contrast that to the wonderful ride, from a very similar position, given by Tom Queally on MIDDAY to win the Filles and Mares Turf on Friday. Tactically and technically, Queally’s judgement was spot-on -- and this in his first-ever Breeders’ Cup ride.
Mind you, Henry Cecil’s pilot cannot escape criticism. For 24 hours later, it was most unedifying to see his wildly excessive use of the whip on TWICE OVER in the Classic. I counted at least 20 fierce backhanders in the final two furlongs, which gave the horse no time to respond and would have landed him with a lengthy ban in this country.
Ryan Moore was similarly hard on CONDUIT in the Turf and while I accept that both were gunning for huge prizes, I will be surprised if the two horses don’t take a long time to recover from their experiences.
Add Murtagh’s shortcomings and the impression left from an entertaining weekend was that, Frankie Dettori and Olivier Peslier excepted, the American jockeys looked far more polished and effective than their European counterparts.
FRIDAY NOVEMBER 6
I must confess that the Breeders’ Cup is beginning to grow on me.
There was a time when I was totally indifferent to the end-of-season jamboree. Particularly because the racing surface, the time of year and the rules on medication loaded the dice against the European challengers. Why do we even bother going over there, I used to ask myself.
My prejudice was fuelled even further in 2007 when the great GEORGE WASHINGTON perished at muddy Monmouth Park. His death remains one of the saddest things I have seen on a racecourse.
However, times have changed. The racing world has moved on. And the temptation of global competition has become hard to resist.
I am still nervous about diving in to have a bet -- simply because I am not confident of my knowledge of American form. LILLIE LANGTRY, VISCOUNT NELSON, ALFRED NOBEL, CONDUIT and ZACINTO all appeal to me over the next two days but can I trust them to be finely tuned and acclimatised in alien surroundings at the end of a long and hard season?
Mind you, at least I’ll be glued in front of the TV, transfixed by the magnificent coverage provided by the US networks. Which is more than could be said of me a few years ago.
I still don’t think the Breeders’ Cup is the event worthy of the sycophancy afforded it in some quarters. And it is still not the definitive Europe v USA showdown. At The Races are even billing it as the World Thoroughbreds Championship. Pardon?!
But few can doubt that this weekend’s meeting at Santa Anita is a fascinating, irresistible occasion, providing a suitable tailpiece for our Flat season.
Let’s hope that the O’Brien, Stoute, Cecil and Godolphin camps can bring home a prize or two.
THURSDAY NOVEMBER 5
Want more evidence that you’re in the right game?
Consider this report prepared for the BHA and entitled Racing Together 2009. It reveals that racing does more work, and earns more money, for charities, communities and good causes than most other sports.
For example, more than 180 charity racedays have generated at least £1.8 million. Open days at trainers’ yards and racing centres have raised more than £700,000 for charity in the last ten years. Racecourse charitable trusts have donated more than £400,000 over the last six years.
Other activities include a Racing To School scheme, whereby more than 55,000 schoolchildren have been helped with their maths, literacy and science skills, plus a Horse Power scheme, whereby children with special needs learn life skills through interaction with horses. Also, youngsters in disadvantaged, inner-city areas are given access to horses, racing and riding as a tool for learning or the potential for employment.
Add to this the work done by rehabilitation centres for retired racehorses and the help given to former jockeys as they seek new careers and it is clear that the sport of racing is far from just a vehicle for gambling.
Full marks to the BHA and its admirable chief executive Nic Coward for bringing the report into the public domain. To read it all, go to britishhorseracing.com
TUESDAY NOVEMBER 3
Do I smell a rat or a red herring?
William Hill reckon they slashed the value of their sponsorship of the big handicap hurdle at Ascot on Saturday because the race was not afforded terrestrial TV coverage.
Oh really?
There was not a terrestrial TV camera in sight at Exeter today -- and yet who sponsored a card worth a whopping £133,000?
Yes, you’ve guessed it. The one and the same William Hill.
MONDAY NOVEMBER 2
With only hours to go before the Melbourne Cup, Down Under, it seems an opportune time to mourn the loss to British racing of ALANDI.
A gritty, fast-improving stayer, John Oxx’s four-year-old won a high-class renewal of the Irish St Leger in the Curragh mud and followed up three weeks later, on very different ground, to deny the likes of Yeats and Kasbah Bliss in another Group One, the Prix du Cadran at Longchamp.
Indeed he looked the natural successor to Yeats and would have taken some stopping in the Ascot Gold Cup next summer.
Sadly Alandi won’t even be there because news has broken that he has been sold by owner the Aga Khan to race in Australia, with the primary aim of winning the Melbourne Cup in 2010.
Given that the staying division is desperately threadbare in this country at present, it is a terrible letdown. Unless Sir Michael Stoute can get PATKAI back on track, next year’s Royal Ascot showpiece could well be the weakest in living memory.
FRIDAY OCTOBER 30
The common perception these days is that the National Hunt game is flourishing and has got its act together in every way, while Flat racing is in crisis.
Utter nonsense, of course. Jumps racing, while magnificent in the main, does have shortcomings to address. Such as too many six-race cards; such as the omission of fences because of low sun; such as the paucity of runners in too many of the decent races outside the Festivals; such as the unedifying sight of tired horses trudging through testing ground in slow-motion finishes; such as the diminishing identity and importance of too many big races through the winter because they are perceived as little more than trials for the Cheltenham Festival.
One area where the Flat is definitely ahead of the National Hunt game is that of 48-hour declarations.
Save for the grumbles of one or two trainers, 48-hour decs have been a godsend, particularly for punters. Preparing in advance matters so much, especially at weekends, so to be able to sit down for an hour or two’s study of Saturday’s Flat cards on a Thursday night, knowing exactly what’s going to run, has been bliss. The extra time has also been particularly valuable during the big week-long festivals, such as those at Royal Ascot, York and Goodwood.
Most of the major meetings over jumps between October and March are staged on Saturdays. So how annoying it is for most punters to have to wait until they return home from work on a Friday evening to find out what’s running. Especially when Friday means a night out for many.
The issue is brought into sharp focus at this time of year when the two codes collide. OK, the system is sometimes at the mercy of changes in weather, which can lead to non-runners. But that can happen with 24-hour decs too. In essence, as far as punters are concerned, the longer the cards are in the public domain beforehand, the more interest those punters are likely to show, which can only benefit the sport. So surely it makes sense to bring the jumps into the line with the Flat.
WEDNESDAY OCTOBER 28
St Nicholas Abbey are the words on everyone’s lips as a humdinger of a Flat season draws to a close. Notwithstanding my comments of yesterday, déjà vu are two words also on mine.
For correct me if I’m wrong but weren’t we in similar awe after last season’s Racing Post Trophy, which was also won by a breathtaking performance from CROWDED HOUSE? And aren’t we getting it similarly wrong about the winner’s main target for 2010?
I have no doubt that St Nicholas Abbey will turn out to be a better three-year-old than Brian Meehan’s colt. But things might have been different if the latter had been prepared for the 2,000 Guineas, rather than the Derby. Because it was pure speed and an electric turn of foot that characterised Crowded House’s Doncaster win. Assets that cried out for him to be campaigned as a miler at three and assets that were also there for all to marvel at in the triumph of Aidan O‘Brien‘s colt four days ago.
The way he was ridden, the way he travelled and the way he picked up and quickened suggest the Guineas must surely be the first port of call for St Nicholas Abbey next spring.
Indeed I am a little surprised that more doubt has not been cast on his suitability for the Derby. OK, like Crowded House (by Rainbow Quest), he is by a rock-solid middle-distance sire in Montjeu, who has already produced the winners of two Epsom Derbies and three Irish versions. But like Crowded House, there is plenty of pace in the pedigree too, especially on the dam’s side. He himself is a brother of a miler, the grandsire was a miler and the dam is a half-sister to a high-class miler.
Yes, I know St Nicholas Abbey’s bloodline is laced with stamina too, featuring sons of the great Sadler’s Wells and the 1990 King George winner Belmez. But in such debates, I always defer to the evidence of my own eyes. Cast your mind back to Saturday. What did you see? Stamina or speed?
TUESDAY OCTOBER 27
A mischievous thought has entered my head regarding the new superstar on the block, Racing Post Trophy winner ST NICHOLAS ABBEY.
Although they would never admit it in public, the Ballydoyle and Coolmore empire must have been hugely miffed to be upstaged by a fellow Irish trainer with SEA THE STARS this season, given the shedloads of money they throw at their admirable racing operation and given the fiercely competitive nature of it.
Most racing followers are in agreement that John Oxx’s colt is one of the greatest horses of all time. Many say he is the best they have ever seen.
And yet…… the decision to retire him now, shunning the Breeders’ Cup and shunning the chance to conquer the world as a four-year-old, having previously shunned the chance to land the Triple Crown, has left the door ajar.
The door ajar for someone to come along and to achieve something even better. To gobble up the same great races Sea The Stars won but also to take in the Breeders’ Cup, maybe even the St Leger along the way, and then to be kept in training to do it all over again.
Impossible? Maybe. But if anyone will be thinking about doing it, it will be O’Brien, Magnier, Tabor, Smith and Co. And the performance of St Nicholas Abbey at Doncaster on Saturday might just have persuaded them to think that little bit harder.
SUNDAY OCTOBER 25
Congratulations to the ‘Racing Post’ on its new, all-colour look, unveiled yesterday.
I can’t decide whether it was genius or folly to announce a related price-increase on the day of its flagship race, the ‘Racing Post Trophy’. But the new look certainly gives the paper a polished, svelte appearance, in keeping with the enormous strides the ‘Post‘ , and its associated website, has made since the instalment of editor Bruce Millington.
There are aspects of the ‘Post’ that I find annoying. Notably many of its columnists and their over-eagerness, at times, to knock the sport. Indeed I feel its stable of columnists could do with an injection of fresh blood. More use should be made of the likes of Laura Thompson and Ian Carnaby, while Lee Mottershead deserves his own column and Dave Nevison and Lydia Hyslop would be welcome ‘new signings’.
Similar negativity often clouds the paper‘s news coverage too. Their current agenda is blighted by an apparent bid to draw a dividing line between Flat racing and jumps racing, which can only be counter-productive. And in the absence of any meaningful competition, the paper often assumes a misplaced, moral high-ground.
But on the whole, the assets of the ‘Post’ far outweigh its shortcomings. As a purveyor of information and statistics, it is a goldmine and unmissable for any serious punter or racing aficionado. The sport is truly blessed.
FRIDAY OCTOBER 23
Tomorrow is a day for giving thanks for racing’s TV coverage.
It’s a day when the best of the end of the Flat season collides head-on with the best of the start of the jumps season.
I could, quite happily, scoot off to Aintree, Chepstow, Doncaster or Newbury -- and feast on a quality card. Instead I’m going to pull up the armchair, turn on the fire and park myself in front of the telly to feast on all four cards at once. Laptop or mobile phone close by in case I fancy a flutter.
I’m able to do this courtesy not only of Channel 4’s terrestrial coverage but also of two dedicated racing channels, both, by and large, slick, professional, informative and successful.
Is any other sport as fortunate as racing in this regard? Why, we even have a national daily newspaper devoted to the sport too.
So let’s stop bleating about the BBC’s attitude towards racing which, incidentally, is far more sensible than it is given credit for, and let’s remember, as AL ZIR storms home in the Racing Post Trophy, how lucky we are.
I only hope the afternoon isn’t spoiled by the forecast heavy rain. Or by Matt Chapman…….
WEDNESDAY OCTOBER 21
Some racing journalists are so cocooned in their Press-box ivory towers that they lose sight of the real world.
Protocol prevents me from naming this one. But he was guilty of an incredible assertion in a recent column. Jumps racing, he said, has “lapped” Flat racing in terms of popularity because trainers, like Paul Nicholls, are more open with the Press and “punters up and down the country believe they get treated so much better through the winter months”.
This is patronising prattle. As if the average racegoer, when taking stock of where he might go racing this coming weekend, will choose Chepstow or Aintree, ahead of Doncaster or Newbury, because that naughty Sir Michael Stoute doesn’t talk to the Press very much.
Let’s expose this myth once and for all. While it would be preferable if all trainers spoke openly about their horses, it boils down to freedom of choice, not to mention obligations to owners, and cannot possibly be made mandatory. The real reason -- and here is the crux -- why some members of the Press fraternity bang on about it so much is, quite simply, because it would make their job far easier.
While on the subject of Press men, with depressing familiarity, Alan Lee, of ‘The Times’, yesterday criticised Champions’ Day at Newmarket because of its crowd figure of 12,500, which he branded “risible”.
In actual fact, such an attendance was perfectly satisfactory, compared to the average figure for the Rowley Mile and considering we are still gripped by recession. Furthermore, it was THREE times bigger than the average daily racecourse-attendance for 2009 and 2,500 higher than the number of signatures the ‘Racing Post’ attracted for its flawed and futile petition against the BBC, despite a rabid campaign.
The main point to make here, though, is that the obsession of Lee and others with measuring the success of meetings by their attendances has become glib, simplistic and misleading, particularly in the digital age, which provides so many platforms for following racing.
Unlike many other sports, such as football, a host of factors needs to be assessed. Not least the size of sponsorship, a field in which Newmarket so excelled, they were able to stage a card worth more than £1.2 million.
And what of the public response? Well, consider this comparison with football. The primary raison d’etre of most football fans is to support their team, which can be most effectively achieved by going to a match. The primary raison d’etre of most racing fans is to have a bet, which does not have to be achieved by going to a meeting.
There might have been only 12,500 behind the gates of the Rowley Mile last Saturday but how many thousands more were following the absorbing action, as it happened, on TV or online or in the betting shops? How many thousands more showed their interest in the meeting by having a flutter?
Lee suggests reforming the format of the meeting and forcing Newmarket to alternate, as its venue, with Ascot and York “to get the punters queueing”. No problem, but he knows that if Champions’ Day was held at Ascot even in its current format, it would attract a crowd of around 25,000 and if it was held at York even in its current format, the gate would probably be nearer 30,000, so he cannot have it both ways. He cannot use attendance figures as a stick with which to beat the meeting.
It is the equivalent of judging Lee‘s newspaper, ‘The Times’, on its circulation figures when held up in comparison to ‘The Sun’ or the ‘Daily Mail’. They are nowhere near as high but that is not to denigrate an excellent paper, nor its place in the overall scheme of things.
Mainly for geographical reasons, Newmarket (as well as other Grade One venues, such as Newbury) cannot attract the gates of the big-city or big-festival tracks. Unless, of course, they are staging sideshow concerts, which excite the non-racing locals and followers of the particular artiste or band.
Champions’ Day does not need Simply Red or Madness to sell it. The event represents high-quality racing in its purest form, appreciated richly by the sport’s dedicated devotees. We must not lose faith in it.
MONDAY OCTOBER 19
‘Hitting a flat spot’ is a well-worn, over-used cliché that is now part and parcel of the racing vernacular. There isn’t anyone in the sport who doesn’t know what it means.
But who coined the phrase? Who is responsible for its universal acceptance?
Could it have been the great INGLIS DREVER? The horse for whom flat spots were obligatory moments in nearly all of his races. Usually about a mile from home and usually followed by relentless surges, or even genuine turns of foot, that would land him major pots, including three Ladbrokes World Hurdles.
It was a characteristic that earned Howard Johnson’s hurdler a place in the hearts of all jumping aficionados. And it is why his death is seriously mourned. Not just because when he dug deep, he dug many a punter out of a financial hole. But also because he possessed the two attributes we all demand most from our equine heroes -- class and guts.
Farewell, old fella.
SATURDAY OCTOBER 17
A message this morning to those of you who believe that Flat seasons require new-fangled, super-sparkly finales. Or at least one not confined to the Bois Du Boulogne or California.
Jump out of bed. Wipe the sleep from your eyes. Remove the National Hunt blinkers, sponsored by the ‘Racing Post’, from your face. Pick up the said ‘Post’. And study the card for Newmarket today.
I defy any of you not to salivate over the quality of such a mouthwatering set of races. And then I defy any of you to devise anything better (within the realms of realism, not fantasy) that could have rounded off what has been a magnificent Flat campaign.
FRIDAY OCTOBER 16
I have been meaning to get this off my chest for a long time now. So here goes.
Why, oh why, when racecards are published in the morning papers are trainers allowed to add the rider “will only run if the ground is suitable”?
What the hell does such irrelevant dross mean? What is their definition of ‘suitable’ for that particular horse? Do they want rain? Do they want sun? Do they want snow? The information is of no use to punters whatsoever.
In these days of increased openness, if there is a doubt about a horse’s participation, the authorities should ensure that trainers are far more specific.
WEDNESDAY OCTOBER 14
So what do you make of the decision to retire SEA THE STARS?
Are you annoyed that he has been deprived of the chance to add the Breeders’ Cup to his string of Group Ones and so claim world domination? After all, the Americans are very insular in their attitudes towards sport and will take some persuading about the greatness of the colt now that he has shirked the chance to beat their own.
Or are you pleased that a line has been drawn under his remarkable career to avoid the risk to his reputation or wellbeing that participation in the Breeders’ Cup might have carried? After all, the American jamboree has limited appeal to a European audience.
You decide.
MONDAY OCTOBER 12
Ideas and recommendations will soon be flowing from the active minds of the Racing For Change brigade. They need to ensure the proposals will genuinely benefit racing and not give the impression of change for change’s sake.
One of the latest ideas is to stage ‘bullet races’ over 4f or even shorter. Apparently the bookies and the racecourses seem to think they will capture the imagination of the public.
I have been going racing now for the best part of 25 years. I have mingled with hundreds of racegoers. I have had conversations with hundreds more, from racing purists to racing virgins. Not once, and I mean not once, have I heard any of them say they wish there were races over trips shorter than 5f.
By all means, let the authorities investigate the plausibility of such races. And if there is a consensus that there is (or could soon be) a sufficient number of horses in training in need of ‘bullet dashes’, then fine, give it a go. But equally, let’s make sure this is not just a gimmick that insults the intelligence of the racing public. Because if it is, they will see through it very quickly and dismiss it with the disdain it deserves.
SATURDAY OCTOBER 10
As the new jumps season gathers momentum at Chepstow and Bangor today, a full-scale row has broken out about the BHA’s new rule to ban the remounting of horses once a race has started.
The reaction of many professionals within the jumping game has been little short of scandalous.
OK, we live in an increasingly politically correct world. But the image of the game is of paramount importance and the welfare of the horse is sacrosanct.
Gone are the days of trainer Tim Forster instructing his Grand National jockeys to “keep remounting”. In this day and age, the practice can be construed by the public as risky, dangerous and cruel.
In my view, the BHA should have banned remounting after the unsavoury sight of Ruby Walsh getting back aboard KAUTO STAR after a fall at the second-last in a novice chase at Exeter in 2005 and setting him alight again as if nothing untoward had happened. Kauto was subsequently injured for nine months and, who knows, we might even have been denied his glorious achievements since.
Better late than never, though, and the BHA are right to implement the ban now. Justification can be found in the outrageous comment attributed to champion jockey Tony McCoy when he was asked why he objected to the ban. “I won £55,000 for an owner when I remounted in the Grand National, so it doesn’t make any sense to ban it,” said McCoy.
Sorry AP, but the horse must come before the money.
FRIDAY OCTOBER 9
It has become almost de rigueur (I’m still in Parisian mode), in many quarters, to predict doom and gloom for racing amid the economic recession. I recall one particular piece by Alastair Down in the ‘Racing Post’ about five or six months ago suggesting the sport was heading for unmitigated disaster.
I hope Down and his ilk have read the findings of a new economic-impact study prepared for the BHA by Deloitte. It reads:
“We are confident the sport has the ability to bounce back once economic conditions improve. An intrinsic advantage that racing has is the passion and commitment of its core followers and participants.
“There are challenges for owners and breeders but racecourse attendances are holding up quite well and media rights revenues are increasing.
“One impact of the recession has been a ‘flight to quality’ where consumers increasingly focus on the top events. Racing has the advantage of having a number of such events and attendances at the big festivals in 2009 have generally held up well.”
Full marks to the BHA, with whom I am increasingly impressed, for shouting about this study from the rooftops. Chief executive Nic Coward has been quick to describe its findings as “striking” and urges everyone within racing to stay positive.
“Racing remains, by a clear margin, the country’s second biggest sport after the modern commercial and social phenomenon that is football,” says Coward.
“The report is not intended to be an exercise in showing off but more people should shout a little louder about things going on in and around the sport, particularly about the impact on the lives of those influenced by it.
“Racing is part of the country’s social fabric and makes an enormous contribution to a wide variety of communities. In spite of the economic downturn, we have a lot to shout about.”
Hear, hear.
THURSDAY OCTOBER 8
The Racing For Change brigade have made it clear that they are determined to attract a younger audience to the sport. People, perhaps, from the same generation as Christopher Tsui, 28-year-old owner of the great SEA THE STARS.
Tsui confesses to being bowled over by all the attention afforded him this season. But what does he think of racing? As a young man, he surely views the sport as old-fashioned, outmoded, floundering in a rut of tradition, ripe for change?
Not a bit of it. And I quote: “I love European racing because this is where you have the history of the thoroughbred and the great races like the Epsom Derby and the Arc. There is so much racing history in Europe and when you study all the great champions, it is fascinating.”
Tsui’s remarks come from a wonderful, enlightening interview by Lee Mottershead, of the ‘Racing Post’, which adds even more to the uplifting experience that everyone in racing seems to have felt through the crowning of Sea The Stars in Paris last Sunday. The interview underlines that, like trainer John Oxx and jockey Mick Kinane, Tsui has handled the horse’s rise to superstardom with professional, dignified aplomb all season.
MONDAY OCTOBER 5
It’s hard enough to win an Arc, the ultimate middle-distance race of the year. It is even harder to win it after a long, hard season that has already taken in five Group One victories, at various trips, tracking back to the first Saturday in May. But to manage it also after the kind of tormented run SEA THE STARS had to endure through the race at Longchamp yesterday is quite extraordinary and utter confirmation that he is, very probably, the greatest horse of all time.
After breaking smartly, jockey Mick Kinane was forced to take a pull of restraint for fear his mount might end up in front. But one pull became several as the colt proved reluctant to play ball and, as a result, he lost his prominent pitch. Although Sea The Stars just about settled eventually, he remained further back than is ideal and almost surrendered his place on the inner as they turned into the home straight, which would have been catastrophic.
What happened next only THE superstars can achieve -- and they don’t come along very often. The colt unleashed breathtaking acceleration and also astonishing dexterity at the same time, quickening while Kinane manoeuvred room for himself, weaving in and out of horses in front. Suddenly, from being in a position that most equine mortals would have found hopeless, Sea The Stars was ahead, clear and on his way to history. Stacked up behind him were no fewer than six Group One winners.
In my pre-race blog on Saturday, I asked for an Arc worthy of its status as the maker and breaker of champions. We got that. Rather crassly, I also asked someone to explain to me why it would be so good for racing if Sea The Stars won it. The horse himself provided the answer. It was a spellbinding exhibition.
With hindsight, the question I posed was churlish and mean-spirited. I knew what I wanted to say. I was annoyed that such a marvellous race as the Arc was being billed as a one-horse party, to which no others were invited. But my message was clumsily and insensitively conveyed.
Now that it’s over, it is all so obvious why Sea The Stars’ triumph is so marvellous for the sport. Because he has elevated standards to heights never occupied before. He has turned the impossible into possible.
Debates will always rage about the best horse ever seen, and the search for a definitive answer is severely hampered by the need to transcend different eras, different generations. But to win the 1,000 Guineas, Derby, Eclipse, International, Irish Champion and Arc in the space of five months is a unique achievement and one unlikely to be matched. To top it off at the Breeders’ Cup would represent Utopia.
Sea The Stars’ achievement is also a timely shot in the arm for Flat racing, at a time when it has become fashionable to deride it, particularly among ‘Racing Post’ opinionists. And it is a timely reminder for the Racing For Change brigade that what matters most within the sport is the product and its protagonists. Never mind the sideshows and the gimmicks. Have the confidence to market and promote the racing itself and to focus on the horse. Surely even Newbury can see the advantage Sea The Stars has over an Abba tribute band.
Also, let’s hear no more of this nonsense about the Flat game lacking ‘narrative’. As he progressed from the Classics against his own age group to taking on the older horses at 10f and then 12f and on to the top international contests around the world, Sea The Stars’ season has underlined that a compelling ‘narrative’ does indeed exist, via an often-criticised, but brilliantly conceived, European Pattern that stands the test of time over and over again.
Now we wait to see if Sea The Stars’ majesty stands the test of time. Somehow, I think it will.
SUNDAY OCTOBER 4
In racing, as a punter, there are very good days, good days, average days, bad days and very bad days.
My personal definition of the latter was yesterday. In fact, it was such a knockout blow that I'm seeing stars..........
SATURDAY OCTOBER 3
Do you get the impression that this weekend’s Arc is being treated in many quarters as a SEA THE STARS’ benefit? Like a testimonial for a cricketer? He turns up, everyone pats him on the back and massages his ego and he rides off into the sunset with all the booty?
With dreary predictability, personalities from within the sport have been wheeled out this week to say how they hope SEA THE STARS wins and how good it would be for racing if he does.
Would someone please explain to me why it would be so good for racing? As if, by implication, it would not be so good if CONDUIT ended the long wait by one of the world’s great trainers, Sir Michael Stoute, to win the race. As if, by implication, it would not be good for racing if DAR RE MI made the French stewards eat humble pie for what happened in the Prix Vermeille by winning the race.
If, as many clearly expect, Sea The Stars trots up, it would be good for the horse and his connections, not to mention the legions of punters who have money on him. But what would be good for racing most of all is an Arc worthy of the race’s great status as the maker and breaker of champions.
Sea The Stars is, of course, already a magnificent champion. But like all champions before him, he cannot be considered a legendary great unless he wins the Arc. It is the ultimate test at the end of a long, hard season for a three-year-old.
The odds have shortened on him managing it after the draw allotted him a handy inside stall. And there is no doubt his price reflects his chance according to the formbook, even if there is a suspicion that he has beaten only the same handful of rivals and has yet to be given a true examination over this 12f trip.
But the idea that racing would, somehow, be doing him some kind of disservice unless he wins is utter nonsense.
Personally, I always prefer my Arc selection to have been prepared specifically for the race. Under the misguided understanding that the race is generally run of Softish ground, John Oxx has been firmly against it for most of the season as a target for Sea The Stars.
In contrast, Sir Michael Stoute has trained Conduit for two assignments this term -- the King George and the Arc. The colt is a three-time Group One winner. He is a Classic winner. A Breeders’ Cup winner. He acts on any ground. He has shown the pace to win over 10f and the stamina to win over 14f. When he was beaten by Sea The Stars in the Coral Eclipse, it was over an inadequate trip under an injudicious hold-up ride. From his modest draw, he will need the ride of a lifetime, this time, from Ryan Moore. But when you erase all the sentimental, patronising hype, there is no doubt he would be as worthy a winner as Sea The Stars.
FRIDAY OCTOBER 2
Having trumpeted the merits of the Cambridgeshire meeting at Newmarket, I must say I have been taken aback by the small size of the fields on the opening two days, particularly today.
It is no surprise to see the two Group One events numerically challenged. After all, there is only so much top-class talent to go round. And in any event, both the Middle Park Stakes and the Cheveley Park Stakes are fantastic renewals.
But why does the Listed event attract only four runners? And why does the £20,000 10f handicap for three-year-olds attract only three runners? Even the two-year-old maiden, which split into two divisions for almost 30 horses last season, boasts a field of only nine. And it beggars belief that the Newmarket Challenge Whip, an anomalous event carrying no prize money whatsoever, can attract as many runners as the Godolphin Stakes worth £40,000.
No doubt the inquest will unfold in the coming days. I look forward to the reasons put forward by owners, trainers, the course and anyone else with a vested interest. It would be tragic if Newmarket was forced to re-think the superb format of this three-day meeting.
THURSDAY OCTOBER 1
The unsatisfactory result of this afternoon’s Group Three Somerville Tattersalls Stakes (won by the 33/1 poke SIR PARKY) continues a curious trend with recent Pattern races for juveniles. What did you make, for instance, of the big two-year-old contests last weekend?
I was desperately disappointed by the Fillies’ Mile and Royal Lodge at Ascot. The former was won by a maiden and the latter by a colt beaten in a Nursery last time.
The Sales races at The Curragh were as fascinating as ever but, again, I was miffed to see them won by juveniles already exposed.
Similarly, I was not as impressed as most by the victory of ST NICHOLAS ABBEY in the Group Two Juddmonte Beresford Stakes.Yes, it was a nice performance from Aidan O’Brien’s colt but nothing more, especially when you consider he was a 2/5 shot in a very ordinary renewal of the race. On a line through the runner-up, his form still has some way to go to match the hype -- or even to match his stablemate, VISCOUNT NELSON, whom I suspect is being wildly under-rated.
WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 30
Hold your bets on the weekend’s big two punting races, the Cambridgeshire and the Prix de l’Arc de Triomphe.
The latest weather- forecast predicts heavy rain for the Newmarket area on Friday night into Saturday. While a maximum field of 20 looks probable for the Arc after the latest declaration stage. That might not frighten SEA THE STARS supporters but a big field adds importance to the draw and it is a telling statistic that 13 of the last 15 Arc winners have been berthed in stalls seven or lower.
TUESDAY SEPTEMBER 29
I do try and bite my lip and stay calm whenever I read Alastair Down’s column in the ‘Racing Post’ these days. I find myself disagreeing with most of his opinions and I am saddened by the fact that once the wittiest and most incisive writer in the game is now, in my estimation, the ‘grumpy old man’ of the racing columnists.
Over the last year or two, Down has given the impression that he has rarely wasted a moment to decry racing and predict doom and gloom for the sport. Whether this be in the shape of a full-blown assault or a quiet aside. All apparently bolstered by the views of half-baked mavericks or by unattributed quotes from anonymous acquaintances.
In recent months, his personal agenda has taken a new twist with attempts to portray racing as, actually, two sports in one. Jump racing, whose virtues must be extolled, and Flat racing, for whom the bell tolls.
This agenda was extended last week when the ‘Post’ conducted a ‘great debate’ over whether racegoers preferred the National Hunt game or the Flat.
Now I totally accept that Down has a right to his own views. It is annoying that they might help to influence opinion within racing, particularly at a time when the mood is for change, but he is an experienced, award-winning journalist whose columns remain widely read.
However it is one thing having an opinion and quite another claiming that the public at large agree with it. So my lip could be bitten no more, and my laptop could be buttoned no more, after reading his latest diatribe in today’s ‘Post’.
Very conveniently, Down is at hand to give his reaction to the findings of the paper’s ‘debate’ on the two codes of racing and the statistics which show that 63% of readers prefer the jumps, 21% the Flat and 16% both. He suggests that such figures should be taken on board and acted upon by the Racing For Change brigade.
What Down fails to acknowledge is that these statistics do NOT relate to a proper survey, poll or vote carried out by the ‘Post’. The 'debate' was never even billed as such. Instead the figures merely relate to the responses by readers who were simply asked to let the ‘Post’ know, via their terrific website, which code they prefer. Crucially, the option of loving BOTH codes was not even touted, yet still 16% of readers went for it. Which suggests to me, very strongly, that had a proper, comprehensive survey been conducted, complete with three options -- jumps, Flat or both -- and embracing ALL 'Post' readers, not just those who use the website, the result would have been very different. Indeed I would go so far as to say that ‘both’ would have won.
Then again, that would not have suited Down’s agenda which, in my opinion, is tantamount to Racing For Division, rather than Racing For Change. Not good at a time when the main priority must surely be to aim for unity at long last among the many parties and interests within the sport.
MONDAY SEPTEMBER 28
Much has been said and written about the curious nature of Ascot's straight track and the unfathomable results it has yielded since being re-laid. But events on Saturday prompted the question: is it the track or is it the way jockeys are riding it?
Things came to a head with a bizarre outcome in the Totesport.com Challenge Cup, the big cavalry-charge handicap of the day over 7f. A literal interpretation of the formbook suggests the far side of the course was heavily favoured. After all, the first seven horses home were drawn 20, 19, 21, 29, 24, 27 and 26!
But did not the jockeys on low-drawn horses hand it to them on a plate by deciding to tack across from the near side? Why did they do it? Unlike at Ayr the previous week, the meeting had provided not a shred of evidence that the far side was the place to be. And the evidence of previous meetings this season was far from conclusive. Indeed the only conclusion with any substance to it was that, in big fields, where the runners were spread across the track, you did not want to be racing up the middle. Yet that is exactly where the low-drawn numbers in the Totesport found themselves! The result was that nearly all, including many of the leading fancies, were beaten before the 1f pole, while the race was won by a 33/1 six-year-old who'd never previously won over the trip!
So, are Ascot punters being led astray not by the draw but rather by jockeys' perception of the draw? Assessing such races is hard enough without having to factor in such imponderables. We can make an educated guess about where the pace of a race is going to be. But predicting whether or not jockeys ride to the draw they have been allocated is nigh on impossible.
THURSDAY SEPTEMBER 24
Please forgive me if the Turfblog goes a bit quieter than normal over the next week or so. I’m off to Ascot for three days this weekend, swiftly followed by three more days at Newmarket next week. And in between time, I’ve somehow got to hold down a full-time job!
The Ascot Festival has perhaps lost a bit of its lustre in recent years. But it is still a terrific meeting, combining quality and variety. And going racing at the ‘new Ascot’ has been much more enjoyable since admirable guru Charles Barnett started calling the shots. Barnett transformed Aintree and he’s even showing signs of making Ascot’s spectacular but spectator-unfriendly grandstand work.
The Cambridgeshire meeting at Newmarket is, in my view, the most under-estimated, unheralded three days’ racing of the entire Flat calendar, particularly on the juvenile front.
There is also a tremendous card at The Curragh on Sunday, not to mention the Arc jamboree at Longchamp to look forward to next weekend.
Great times! Best of luck and see you soon!
TUESDAY SEPTEMBER 22
I am pleased to hear that Racing UK have all but achieved the 30,000 subscribers they need to survive as a viable, stand-alone TV channel after the demise of their partner, Setanta Sports.
Setanta going bust was hardly their fault and the decision to revert to their £20-per-month fee did not warrant the criticism it received in some quarters.
Many of the critics wrote to, or even work for, the ‘Racing Post’. Yet to buy the RP every day adds up to £11.50 per week or £46 per month.
It beggars belief how anyone can argue that £20 to have access to some of the world’s best racing, either via your TV or laptop, is anything but sensational value for money. I vehemently disagree with Racing UK’s insistence that we must pay extra for a second TV/box (unless it is to be used for commercial purposes) but that’s a discussion for another day.
Mind you, as generous subscribers, we now have the right to demand answers to questions. Questions such as: why don’t Racing UK broadcast the breadth of programmes featured on the free-to-air At The Races channel? And why is the RUK website lamentably worse than ATR’s?
And we can also demand standards of high quality. Unlike those spotted in RUK’s latest ‘Club Magazine’. The publication is a decent read, particularly the brilliant Nick Luck’s illuminating views on the crackpot notion that jockeys and trainers should be forced to speak to the media as a condition of their licences.
However it lets itself down badly in the ‘What’s On’ section, which previews forthcoming big meetings to be shown by RUK. On November 28, apparently, we can see the Hennessy Gold Cup from Newbury, which “has been won four times in the past by the mighty Florida Pearl”. Wow! They must have been some weight-carrying performances!
SUNDAY SEPTEMBER 20
Is it just me or does anyone else find the Ayr Gold Cup the hardest race of the year to solve? At the risk of sounding like Tom Segal during a bad run (which he palpably isn’t at the moment!!), I simply cannot fathom it.
I have twice backed the winner at tasty odds. Funnily enough, both horses were trained by Richard Hannon -- WILDWOOD FLOWER and PRESTO SHINKO. But don’t ask me how or why. Most years, there just seem to be too many imponderables to conquer.
At the ante-post stage, you start wondering whether or not your horse will even get a run. My fancy this time round, ROKER PARK, missed the cut by five.
Next you wonder about the state of the ground. This week, Ayr was Soft at the start of the week, yet the race was run on a fastish surface.
Next, you have the draw, and all the crazy theories surrounding it, to contend with. Again, the week began with most ‘experts’ sure you needed a high stall. After the Silver Cup and the new Bronze Cup, it appeared clear you needed a low berth. But even then, many felt it didn’t matter. It was a case of needing to be where the pace is.
The fact that this year’s renewal was won by a horse in JIMMY STYLES who had become a desperate disappointment since starting favourite for the Wokingham at Royal Ascot and by a trainer in Clive Cox who was unable to claim the draw he wanted because his phone wouldn’t work just about summed up the whole shenanigan.
For Ayr Gold Cup, read Headache Gold Cup!
FRIDAY SEPTEMBER 18
A quick quiz for you today. Can you spot the odd one out among these sporting scandals? Which are real and which is made up?
BLOODGATE (RUGBY UNION) -- one of the country’s top teams, Harlequins, and former England star Dean Richards are accused, of, and found guilty of, cheating by faking an injury, using a toy blood-capsule, to gain an advantage. Public outrage.
DIVEGATE (FOOTBALL) -- one of the country’s leading strikers, Eduardo, is vilified and accused of cheating after apparently taking a dive to win a penalty for Arsenal in a Champions League tie against Celtic. Public outrage.
GENDERGATE (ATHLETICS) -- one of the world’s top runners, 18-year-old South African Caster Semenya, is accused of cheating by storming to victory in the women’s 800m World Championships when she is, in fact, a man. Public outrage.
CRASHGATE (MOTOR RACING) -- one of the top Formula One teams, Renault, are accused of cheating by ordering driver Nelson Piquet Jnr to crash deliberately and so help teammate Fernando Alonso to victory in last year’s Singapore Grand Prix. Public outrage.
LEGERGATE (HORSE RACING) -- two horses from the one of the country’s leading stables, Godolphin, are neck and neck in the final furlong of one of the year’s top races, the St Leger. The jockey on their number two contender and lesser fancied horse, MASTERY, lets the jockey on their number one contender and the favourite, KITE WOOD, win the contest.
And they reckon racing is bent.
WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 16
It's not often that you can rely on brash Yorkshire trainer Dandy Nicholls for a calm dose of realism to diffuse a piece of controversy.
But he is spot-on in his assessment of the disqualification of DAR RE MI in the Group One Prix Vermeille at Longchamp on Sunday.
Says Nicholls simply: "Read the French rule-book". And once anyone has done so, it becomes clear that the decision of the stewards was perfectly reasonable. Harsh but a reasonable interpretation of the rulebook as it stands in France.
One can understand the fury of connections and of punters who backed Dar Re Mi to upset the hot favourite STACELITA. John Gosden's filly was clearly the best filly in the race and, at 20/1 with Stan James, she now represents good each/way value for the Arc.
But all suggestions that the stewards reacted with xenophobic tendencies or that connections would be justified in appealing against the decision are misguided.
Under British rules, of course, Dar Re Mi would have kept the race. And from a punting perspective, our rules are far preferable. The fewer horses that are thrown out, the better.
But those getting hysterical about Sunday's decision should direct their ire at attempts to harmonise the rules across Europe and the rest of the world. A level playing-field is clearly what is required.
MONDAY SEPTEMBER 14
My four days’ punting at Doncaster’s Leger Festival were not particularly successful. However I felt I did little wrong. Made very few bad decisions. It was just the way the cookie crumbled. Lots of seconds and pieces of bad luck. You know the kind of thing.
In contrast, I am overwhelmed today by a feeling of sheer frustration at two bad decisions I made in races at The Curragh over the weekend. The failure to be brave enough to back, or even tip, KINGSFORT and BORDER PATROL, even though I identified both of them earlier in the season as potential stars.
Both represented glaringly good value against short-priced favourites from the Aidan O’Brien yard. And yet I wasn’t courageous enough to ignore the worry that both were stepping up in class and both were coming back from long absences.
Class told. By surging home in the Group One National Stakes on Saturday, Kingsfort underlined that he is a serious prospect for Classic glory next season. This is always a hugely reliable race and Kevin Prendergast’s colt must be some animal to win it on the back of a sole maiden win and after being laid low, in the meantime, by a virus. By grinding down the favourite in a Group Three contest yesterday, Border Patrol showed that he must be respected in any company at 7f or 1m, providing the ground is not too quick. This was only the fifth start of his career and he has improved for every one.
SUNDAY SEPTEMBER 13
So was the Leger rescued by a top-class performance? The simple answer is no.
In a nutshell, MASTERY outstayed his stablemate, KITE WOOD, on ground a shade too lively for the latter. Kite Wood would have won with cut in the ground. There again, MONITOR CLOSE would have won had his stamina not given way in the final furlong, so strongly did he travel up to that point. And there again, on his form in front of Mastery in France, AGE OF AQUARIUS would have won had he not suffered a late setback.
Ifs and buts that sum up the 2009 Leger really. Lacking in outstanding quality.
It must be the first time the Leger has been won by a horse that had been well beaten earlier in the season in the Queen's Vase, a Group Three 2m event at Royal Ascot. Mind you, I did suspect at the time that it was an above-average renewal. Mastery was third, behind the very impressive winner, Mark Johnston's HOLBERG, who has not been seen since because of injury, and YANKEE DOODLE, of Aidan O'Brien's, who went on to run well behind ALANDI, the gritty winner of the top-class Irish Leger, which was also staged yesterday.
Holberg's re-appearance, very possibly for Godolphin next season, is now eagerly awaited, while the subsequent efforts of Yankee Doodle suggest he might have been a better choice for the race than his Ballydoyle stablemate CHANGINGOFTHEGUARD, who was disappointing in his first crack at Group company.
The sub-standard Doncaster showpiece failed to detract from the four-day meeting as a whole, which was a success, I thought. Clearly helped by a gift from the gods in the form of glorious weather , it was capped by a bumper crowd of 30,000 on Leger Day itself.
Surprisingly, I felt the course coped well with such a turnout. Lessons had clearly been learned from previous years. Bars and food outlets were well staffed and strategically placed to ensure the crowd was evenly spread, and queues and congestion were limited.
My only complaints concerned the main stand. It is one of the newest in the country, so why is it not blessed with an air-conditioning system? Or if it is, one that works. I accept that the management were probably taken by surprise by the warm weather but the public areas inside the County Enclosure were uncomfortably clammy.
Even more uncomfortable would have been Trades Descriptions Act watchdogs had they been present to read the track’s promotional blurb about a stand that promises “panoramic views of the famous Town Moor course”.
As I touched on in this column last year, and others have touched on since, it does no such thing -- unless, maybe, if you’re lucky enough to be waited on in one of the highest corporate-hospitality boxes that rise into the South Yorkshire sky. Pay at the turnstiles and take your place on the public terracing or in the public seats and your view of the whole of the back straight is blocked by a double-decker hospitality building, a funfair and an array of trees, all inconveniently situated in the middle of the course. In other words, from the Leger start to the turn into the home straight (more than 1m), you see virtually nothing.
A plethora of big screens are on hand, of course, to show the action as it unfolds. But the best way to watch on a screen is to stay at home. Racecourses that are unable to provide a decent view of what their customers pay for -- and Doncaster are not alone on this -- are playing a dangerous, risky game.
THURSDAY SEPTEMBER 10
There have been one or two sub-standard St Legers in recent seasons. But has there ever been a renewal of the great Classic that has captured the imagination less than Saturday's race?
It really is looking a most threadbare affair. A field of only eight runners, half of which hail from the big-gun yards of Ballydoyle and Godolphin, is irksome enough. But of those eight, are there any we can describe as true Group One material?
Today's defection of one of the favourites, AGE OF AQUARIUS, virtually drills the final nail in the Leger 2009 coffin.
Let's hope, somehow, the race is rescued by a performance worthy of its grand tradition.
WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 9
I can't remember the last time I saw a handicap split into two divisions. Certainly not at one of our major festivals.
So full credit to Doncaster today for showing the initiative to turn a six-race card into seven by dividing the concluding sprint handicap.
The first day of the meeting is the weakest by some way and was made even weaker by the fact that it carried only six races.
'Donny' has made a conscious decision in recent seasons to overload the final two days of the Leger Festival with their better events. But I can't help thinking that the opening Wednesday could do with a Group race or decent handicap to inject more quality or interest and get the meeting off to a roaring start. In the past, of course, the Portland Handicap, now run on the Saturday and rather lost amid the Leger countdown, was the headline feature.
TUESDAY SEPTEMBER 8
IT'S my birthday today. A date I share with such luminaries as Peter Sellers, Siegfried Sassoon, Yves Saint-Martin, Geoff Miller, Pink, Graham Bradley, Anne Diamond, Paul Hanagan, Patsy Cline and Slim Thug. Make of that lot what you will!
I am long past the stage where it's worth celebrating, although I am looking forward to four days at Doncaster's St Leger Festival, starting tomorrow.
I like the meeting. The cards are balanced, mixing competition with class. I particularly like the Listed and Condiitions races they stage. These are ideal for horses just below Group level, horses on the upgrade and those returning from injury or trying to regain confidence.
I like the track, although I do miss the magnificent viewing from the second tier of the old grandstand.
And I believe I am one of the few people in the country who actually likes the town itself! I accept that the nightlife is a unique, acquired taste (!) but it is worth sampling and, in years gone by, 'Donny' was always the preferred destination for the all-day, bus-trip racedays I used to organise from my home town.
There weren't many better pub-crawls than that long walk back from the course into the town centre, especially after a winning day! And by the time you got back to the town centre, anything could happen -- and often did!
MONDAY SEPTEMBER 7
Tipster Tom Segal, aka Pricewise of the ‘Racing Post’, makes me chuckle. I am amused when he openly sulks in his columns during bad runs without winners and blames the tracks for his own shortcomings. Goodwood and Ascot consistently receive flak. To such an extent this year that Segal made the extraordinary assertion, after another traumatic week on the Sussex Downs, that the reason he can’t tip winners at Goodwood is because it doesn’t suit the kind of horses he goes for -- animals who are held up on the inside rail. Too many, he reasoned, get blocked in and don’t get a run.
In a further veiled dig, he lauded the appeal of York as a galloping track and made the preposterous prediction that the fare at this year’s Ebor Festival would be better than Royal Ascot!
How hilarious it was, then, when his big tip of the week, CHANGINGOFTHEGUARD in the Ebor itself, was given just the kind of ride he purports to support, held up on the inner -- only to be denied victory because jockey Johnny Murtagh got hemmed in!
Anyway, the reason I’m focusing on Segal is because his current woes continued yesterday when he got himself in another almighty muddle while assessing the Prix du Moulin at Longchamp. He decried the chances of the eventual winner, AQLAAM, because of his outside draw, completely forgetting that, in France, horses with low draws race on the inner!
Notwithstanding such a schoolboy error, Segal deserves full marks for being brave enough to tackle the big autumn handicaps, the Cambridgeshire and the Cesarewitch, in a couple of ante-post ‘Pricewise’ specials in the RP last week.
At this stage, with more than 100 entries remaining in each, the races look impossible to solve.
Segal has somehow narrowed it down to one or two recommended bets. The best I can do is narrow it down to NINE possibles for the Cambridgeshire and SEVEN for the Ces!!
For the record, these are: CAMBRIDGESHIRE -- Sirvino, Foolin Myself, Shamali, Alazeyab, Fareer, Invisble Man, Tryst, Credit Swap and Applause. CESAREWITCH -- Darley Sun, Swingkeel, Aajel, Wells Lyrical, Saga De Tercey, Alanbrooke and Hawk Mountain.
SUNDAY SEPTEMBER 6
Regular readers of this column will know that I bow to no-one in my admiration of the skills of dual-purpose trainer John Quinn. His ability to churn out winners with all types of horses, both on the Flat and over jumps, bears the hallmark of genius.
So one can only imagine the devastation and grief that must have ripped through his Malton yard since the news broke of the death of one of Quinn’s apprentices, Jamie Kyne, in a fire at nearby Norton.
Under Quinn’s shrewd tutelage, Jamie (18) had quickly developed into one of the best apprentice jockeys in the country.
The sense of loss is so great that the tragedy has sadly overshadowed all the headline-making events on the track this weekend -- most notably the continued brilliance of SEA THE STARS, the comeback of Kieren Fallon, the wonderfully gritty victory of REGAL PARADE in the Betfred Sprint Cup and the masterstroke by trainer John Gosden to apply cheekpeices to entice a return to the Group One winner’s enclosure by RAINBOW VIEW.
My deepest sympathies and condolences go out to all the family and friends of Jamie Kyne and 19-year-old fellow apprentice Jan Wilson, who also perished in the fire.
FRIDAY SEPTEMBER 4
So Kieren Fallon, six-times champion jockey, is back. Riding on British tracks for the first time in more than three years.
And boy, hasn’t he made sure the world knows it! The PR machine has hit overdrive in recent weeks as Fallon has made himself available to every racing and sports journalist under the sun. The coverage has been comprehensive, to say the least, and Fallon has not been slow in coming forward about his prospects. “Back me with all the money you’ve got,” he is reported to have told one journo asking about a bet to become champion jockey in 2010.
We now sit back and wait to see if the hype is justified. Can he rekindle the magic flame? Is he really a changed personality?
Fallon is a man who polarises opinion within racing. He arouses strong views, both for and against. But there is little doubt he has been, and might well be again, an outstanding jockey and a gifted horseman. One of the best of the modern era. I still drool over the ride he gave KRIS KIN to win the 2003 Derby. I talk through my pocket but it was a ride that had control, finesse, judgement, timing, courage, strength, the lot.
As far as his well-documented misdemeanours go, I’m a great believer in doing time for the crime and starting from a clean slate afterwards. Racing should welcome him back.
However the tone of the fanfare to herald his comeback has been unduly hysterical in some quarters. One racing columnist with a national newspaper, whose opinions I normally respect, profferred preposterous notions that Flat racing has been dull because of Fallon’s absence and forecast that he would return with a blitzkrieg of winners. The ‘Racing Post’ threatened to follow a similarly OTT direction earlier in the week but retrieved the correct balance with wise, sensible pieces today by James Willoughby and David Ashforth that sounded proper notes of caution.
Fallon’s comeback is sure to enrich the sport and add fascination, intrigue, colour and drama. But he comes back as one player in a huge game that has moved on since he booted home DYLAN THOMAS in the 2007 Arc. He has a long way to go before he can be considered champion-jockey material again and also before he can be considered ‘changed-person’ material. Yes, he’s happy, smiling and relaxed now. Raring to prove a point. But aren’t we all after a holiday? The test will come when the daily grind of riding, travelling, riding, travelling kicks in again. When the pressure mounts and when the searching demands he and his PR machine have placed on him over the last few days need to be justified.
THURSDAY SEPTEMBER 3
In recent days, fellow fanatics will, no doubt, have received through the post their paraphernalia from Cheltenham and Aintree, reminding that it’s time to book tickets for the jumps season. It’s always an exciting, if expensive, moment!
Recouping the cost with a successful ante-post bet is harder than it sounds. But scanning through the ante-post lists this morning, I note that ZAYNAR, whom I advised at 16s at the end of last season, is still available with Coral at 14/1 for the Champion Hurdle.
For me, that is a very attractive price for a horse still on the upgrade. Given that Victor Chandler is a part-owner, it could be significant that his firm are as low as 8/1.
TUESDAY SEPTEMBER 1
A new month -- and a terrific one for racing, in my opinion, what with Betfred Sprint Cup day at Haydock and the marvellous St Leger meeting, followed by two excellent and informative days at Newbury, plus the Ayr Gold Cup, and all topped off by what used to be known as the Ascot Festival.
It’s hard to remember two more unsatisfactory Leger trials than those we have had at Goodwood and York this season. The form of the Gordon Stakes is not working out at all, while the Great Voltigeur was an utter mess.
KITE WOOD is a solid, worthy favourite for the final Classic. It’s hard to crab his victory over older rivals at Newbury last time. But is he sexy enough to win a Leger?
I’m yet to be convinced and I’m pleased I had the foresight to have a bit on CHANGINGOFTHEGUARD at 16s before he ran so well in the Ebor. But potentially by far the most fascinating challenger to Kite Wood is Henry Cecil’s rangy, exciting colt MANIFEST.
He has yet to be supplemented and because he has only contested maidens, all the Doncaster stats and trends are against him. All recent Leger winners had previously run in some form of Group race, while most had contested a Derby (Changingoftheguard, incidentally, won the Ulster Derby!!)
But Manifest was staggeringly impressive at Newmarket last time and has earned rave reviews on the gallops, not to mention a seal of approval from Kieren Fallon. By all accounts, the colt left stablemate FATHER TIME for dead over the weekend.
Now Father Time is no superstar and disappointed in the Voltigeur. But he’s no mug either. After all, he is a Royal Ascot winner. If the gallops report is to be believed, Teddy Grimthorpe and Co are surely going to find it very hard to resist stumping up the cash to saddle Manifest on the Town Moor on September 12.
MONDAY AUGUST 31
I’ve had time to reflect on a letter I had published by the ‘Racing Post’ yesterday. It was written a little in the heat of the moment. At a time when I was spitting feathers. But I’m pleased I sent it.
My main motivation for the missive was a response to comments made by Stephen Higgins, managing director of Newbury racecourse, who himself was responding to criticism of the track at their Simply Red concert day on August 15.
If you recall, the day was hailed a huge success by the track because it attracted a record crowd of 26,000. But by all accounts, many regular racegoers did not enjoy the experience one bit, mainly because, unbelievably, the stage erected for the concert blocked the view from the stands of the racing between the 3f and 1f markers!
Higgins tried to justify the decision and what drove me to the pen was his comment that “Racing alone is not always sufficient to drive attendances.” A shocking admission, if ever I’ve read one.
“Was this the pivotal moment when racecourse managers finally gave up on the sport they serve?” I wrote.
I continued in similar vein, questioning why racecourses like Newbury do not promote their fine, quality racing with as much energy and vigour as their ‘cashflow sideshows’.
I am not against post-racing concerts. Providing racecourse managers are honest and admit that they exist to fill the coffers. There is little or no evidence that they are encouraging more people to go racing, while there IS evidence that they are in danger of alienating regular racegoers. And when they physically hamper or handicap the primary reason why tracks exist (ie: blocking the view of the racing) it should come as no surprise when those regular racegoers complain and say: hold on, that’s a step too far.
The ‘Post’ published Mr Higgins’s response to my letter. It is a reasonable defence of the course’s position. But I do feel strongly that racing purists/fanatics/addicts, call us what you will, speak up in situations like this. Sadly, we have no official body or organisation within the sport that will do it for us and if we don’t speak out, our views will be trampled on.
I love Newbury and I love going racing there. It is one my top-three favourite courses in the country. The racing and its facilities, in my view, are spot-on. But there is a balance to be found between looking after your core customers and attempting to woo new customers. A fine line has to be trod. I believe Newbury stepped the wrong side of the line on August 15 and, judging by the way they market their Flat season, they could soon be taking giant strides the wrong side. Only by disaffected people standing up and saying so will they start to think twice or to think again.
Anyone who hasn’t seen my letter and wants to have a look at it should contact me at richard.silverwood@sky.com I will send it by return e-mail.
SUNDAY AUGUST 30
The ‘Racing Post’, too often depressingly negative about racing, gets full marks today for the most inspirational and uplifting article by Brough Scott.
It focuses on an idea by the Horsemen’s Group to put together a promotional film extolling the virtues of racehorse-ownership -- and their success in persuading stars and celebrities to feature in it.
Michael Holding tells how his first winner as an owner was better than taking ten wickets in a Test match. Judi Dench tells how she was reduced to tears when her horse, Smokey Oakey, won the Lincoln.
But it is actor James Nesbitt who steals the show, and the article. Savour this: “The first thing I would do is encourage people to go racing. People are turned off the idea because they don’t think it is for them. They don’t understand the majesty of the spectacle, the thrill of entering this vast arena filled with people with the right bonhomie all focused on this one, sharp, exclusive event. Racing is good for the spirit. Good if you win, sad if you lose, but still great. You can get as much pleasure in moaning about your losses as celebrating your victory. But what I have really discovered about owning a horse is how adored and cherished the animals are by the trainers and lads and everyone.”
There is more of the same, lots more, and I urge you to try and read the article, if you can. What’s more, I reckon it should be pinned on the walls of everyone involved in the Racing For Change initiative.
SATURDAY AUGUST 29
I’m often asked what kind of horse I would love to own. I usually reply any that proved good enough to run at either the Cheltenham Festival or Royal Ascot. But watching Newmarket on TV today brought the definitive answer -- an animal with the talent and amazing consistency and durability of THE TATLING.
He’s been on the go since 1999! He’s now 12 years old and this was his 129th race! Of those 129 races, he’s now finished in the first three 52 times -- not far off a 50% strike-rate -- and won prize money in excess of £673,000. Now that’s what I call a dream horse to own.
FRIDAY AUGUST 28
A healthy debate is raging within racing at the moment about York’s decision to extend their Ebor Festival to four days. Sadly, it is lacking a contribution of any significance from the course itself, which seems happy to rely on the glib terminology of the marketing men.
I am fiercely protective of York. Along with the Cheltenham Festival, the Ebor meeting was the first major meeting I made a point of staying away for, back in the 1980s. Terrific racing in a wonderful city.
Personally, I have no complaints about the switch to four days and it puzzles me how York can possibly deny what even the dumb and dumber realise -- that the move has been undertaken to make more money.
However I have one large proviso -- that each day’s card carries SEVEN races, rather than six.
The three-day festival had seven races per day. A programme of only six races on each of the four days undoubtedly dilutes the appeal of the meeting.
Of the major meetings, only the Cheltenham Festival and Royal Ascot can get away with six races per day. York’s fare isn’t strong enough.
The handicaps sometimes lack quality, while the Group races sometimes lack strength in depth and a competitive edge. OK, it was great to see SEA THE STARS and SARISKA in two of the meeting‘s Group One events. But only one serious rival turned up to take each of them on, while the 2m Lonsdale Cup was possibly the worst Group Two I have ever seen.
On a six-race card, it only takes one of the races to come up short to devalue the whole day. York 2009 was still most enjoyable. The course continues to get most things right. But only the fourth and final day of York 2009 delivered all the goods, in my view.
Whether the racing community agree with me or not, only time will tell. But whatever they might say in public, I’m not so sure that the hierarchy at the Knavesmire will be too pleased with the figures from the first four-day festival, revealing that the total number of spectators rose by only 7% from the last three-day format in 2007.
Ensuring value for money is the easiest way to improve those figures -- and adding an extra race each day is the obvious option available.
FEEDBACK
IF you have any comments on this column or on racing topics in general, e-mail me at richard.silverwood@sky.com
.
|