Lyra McKee murder accused released on bail

A judge rejected an appeal against a decision that Gearoid Peter Cavanagh, 33, and Jordan Devine, 21, should be released from custody.

The pair are accused of involvement in events surrounding the dissident republican killing in Derry.

Ms McKee, 29, was shot dead while she observed rioting in the Creggan area on April 18, 2019.

Neither Cavanagh, of Elmwood Terrace in Derry, nor Devine, from Synge Court in the city, are accused of firing the fatal shot.

But they were charged with the journalist’s murder following a review of available identification evidence.

Both men face further counts of possessing a firearm and ammunition with intent to endanger life, riot, possession of petrol bombs, throwing petrol bombs and arson.

At Derry Magistrates’ Court last week they were granted bail along with a third defendant, 21-year-old Joe Campbell from Gosheden Cottages in Derry, who is charged with rioting and petrol bomb offences on the night Ms McKee was killed.

The Public Prosecution Service mounted an appeal in an attempt to prevent all three men’s release, claiming there was a risk of serious further offences.

The court heard charges were brought after comparing footage an MTV documentary crew recorded at the scene and earlier that day at dissident republican political party Saoradh’s offices.

It was contended that Devine can be identified standing close to the gunman, cheering and punching the air as the shots were fired.

He also allegedly threw missiles at police and picked up misfired rounds from the ground.

Cavanagh is the masked figure on the footage who escorted the gunman to and from the scene, the prosecution claim.

At one point he also allegedly stewarded the crowd.

The gun used to kill Ms McKee, a .22 pistol, was discovered in a hollow behind a telegraph pole during searches in the city’s Ballymagroarty area in June last year.

It was also used in four New IRA punishment shootings in Derry between September 2018 and March 2019, the court heard.

Defence lawyers argued that the charges were based on weak and fiercely disputed evidence.

Questioning alleged identification from footage of individuals wearing mass-produced items of clothing, they claimed the prosecution case was doomed to failure.

His Honour Judge Stephen Fowler QC was also told that another man charged with Ms McKee’s murder, 53-year-old Paul McIntrye, of Kinnego Park in Derry, has been on bail for more than a year.

On that basis he ruled that all three defendants before him should also be released from custody.

“It’s difficult to distinguish the case against McIntyre and that against Devine and Cavanagh,” Judge Fowler said,

“The prosecution have not sought to differentiate between these applicants and McIntyre in terms of involvement.

“Accordingly, for those reasons I’m minded to grant bail.”

He imposed curfews, ordered the accused to report to police three times a week and banned them from contacting each other.

They are also excluded from the Creggan and Brandywell areas of Derry under the terms of bail.