We will see GP Services without GPs in the near future - Medical Matters with Derry GP Dr Tom Black
Taxi drivers are now complaining about the NHS which is saying something given the state of the roads with potholes.
Taxi drivers are very similar to GPs in that they’re dealing with the public directly to provide a service where the demand often exceeds capacity especially at peak times, and as with GPs taxi drivers suffer continuous comment and complaint. To stay on the road taxi drivers need GP appointments to stay healthy and for their taxi driver medicals. Like everyone else they’re struggling to access the GP services and there are now multiple private providers operating in this area offering appointments.
The NHS that we used to have lasted for about 80 years but just as driverless taxis will appear on London streets later this year so we will see GP Services without GPs in the near future. We have seen a 20% decrease in GP numbers in the Northwest in the last five years and this rapid reduction will continue as young GPs go to work in the Republic of Ireland and to the new private GP services that seem to be opening up everywhere. Young GPs will leave the NHS because the alternative employers for their skills pay more money for less onerous work. Could you blame them? You might be tempted to if you’re an older GP unable to retire!
The NHS will adapt by introducing artificial intelligence services and we already see Westminster and Stormont discussing this in their neighbourhood plans. Your phone call or email will be dealt with by an NHS chatbot which (who?) in many cases will be able to sort out your prescription request or minor ailment without any human being involved. If this sounds like pie in the sky, it’s worth pointing out the 28% of GPs in the UK already use AI in their job and this number will now increase rapidly as computer clinical systems integrate AI into workflows.


There’s no doubt that young people and computer geeks will have a huge advantage in their use and access to this new NHS but just as older folk were slow to use mobile phones a generation ago they will adapt and use the new systems because they will be disadvantaged if they don’t.
The strange thing about artificial intelligence is that people automatically assume that the machine AI will be less empathetic than a human doctor but research suggests the patients are more comfortable with a chatbot and more likely to report substance abuse, intimate partner violence, sexual behaviour and workload stress as the patient doesn’t have to worry about the human doctor being judgemental.
All of these changes will take place much faster than we expect and there are risks associated with early phase adoption.
We need to make sure that the AI used is safe and accurate and has clear governance structures. We should be concerned about the risks of commercial exploitation and we’re already hearing stories of ICE agents in the USA misusing clinical data to track down individuals.


In a world with huge increases in mental health disorder, neuro diversity and social media hysteria there is also a risk that AI chatbot sycophancy makes us all into passive patients dependent and addicted to our AI intimate carer. What will you call yours?
Strange times indeed.