Green light for A5 Derry to Dublin road as Court of Appeal overturns decision

A Stormont Department was legally entitled to approve the £1.7bn A5 road upgrade, the Court of Appeal has ruled.

Senior judges overturned a decision that plans for the biggest infrastructure project of its kind ever undertaken in Northern Ireland did not comply with climate change targets.

In a verdict which now clears the way for the scheme, Lady Chief Justice Dame Siobhan Keegan confirmed previous findings made by the High Court should not stand.

“The legal obligations to achieve net zero by 2050 is not a prohibition upon the authorisation for a new road where it has been assessed, as far as possible, to be consistent with emission reduction obligations,” she said during the hearing on Tuesday.

A5 campaigners outside Laganside Courts in Belfast. Liam McBurney/PA Wireplaceholder image
A5 campaigners outside Laganside Courts in Belfast. Liam McBurney/PA Wire

“The fundamental error the judge made was his failure to consider how the decision fitted within climate targets across Northern Ireland as a whole.”

In 2024 the Department for Infrastructure (DfI) approved plans to develop a 58-mile stretch of the A5 between Derry and Aughnacloy, Co Tyrone.

More than 50 people have been killed on the road since 2006, according to official figures.

In June last year a High Court judge held that the dual carriageway should not go ahead in its current form.

Julie McGeehan (left) and her father Patsy McSorley (right), whose mother and wife Julia McSorley was killed in an A5 crash alongside Mrs McSorley’s nephew Dan McKane and niece Christine McKane, with crash survivor Collette McKane (centre), outside Laganside Courts in Belfast, where the Court of Appeal is due to rule on a Stormont legal challenge over the blocking of the A5 road upgrade..Liam McBurney/PA Wireplaceholder image
Julie McGeehan (left) and her father Patsy McSorley (right), whose mother and wife Julia McSorley was killed in an A5 crash alongside Mrs McSorley’s nephew Dan McKane and niece Christine McKane, with crash survivor Collette McKane (centre), outside Laganside Courts in Belfast, where the Court of Appeal is due to rule on a Stormont legal challenge over the blocking of the A5 road upgrade..Liam McBurney/PA Wire

It followed a legal challenge against authorising construction work mounted by an umbrella group of local residents and landowners known as the Alternative A5 Alliance.

The Alliance claims the upgrade will have a negative impact on farmland and the environment.

Ruling in their favour, Mr Justice McAlinden had identified a failure to demonstrate the scheme would comply with targets set out in the 2022 Climate Change Act. Section 52 of the Act imposes an obligation on Stormont departments to meet carbon emission targets and achieve the overall net-zero goal by 2050.

He also found flaws in properly showing consideration of human rights issues by not imposing a time limit for construction, and compliance with an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA).

The A5 road. Picture by Stephen Davison.placeholder image
The A5 road. Picture by Stephen Davison.

Further consultation on methodology for estimating greenhouse gas emissions from induced traffic on the A5 was required before the scheme could go ahead, according to the judge.

The project, which forms part of a proposed key cross-border business route linking Dublin and the north west, has already been held up due to previous legal actions.

Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins appealed the High Court verdict in a bid to ensure the road gets built.

Stormont colleague Andrew Muir, Minister at the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA), has also intervened to support her appeal.

Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins (left) speaking with Niall McKenna, chairperson of the A5 - Enough is Enough group, outside Laganside Courts in Belfast, where the Court of Appeal is to rule on the Stormont legal challenge to blocking of the A5 road upgrade.Liam McBurney/PA Wireplaceholder image
Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins (left) speaking with Niall McKenna, chairperson of the A5 - Enough is Enough group, outside Laganside Courts in Belfast, where the Court of Appeal is to rule on the Stormont legal challenge to blocking of the A5 road upgrade.Liam McBurney/PA Wire

Lawyers for both Departments argued that the High Court’s analysis had got it wrong.

Counsel for the DfI insisted it did deal with emissions in an assessment which considered the cross-border difference in any induced traffic.

Figures demonstrated that the A5 was not likely to generate much of an increase, it was claimed.

A barrister for the DAERA Minster argued that the road upgrade was wrongly blocked due to a misinterpretation of Northern Ireland’s climate change laws.

He insisted all checks were carried out to ensure it will not stymie the objective of achieving net-zero greenhouse emissions by 2050.

Campaign group Enough is Enough, which represents families of some of those killed on the road, backed the appeal.

It argued that rights to life and ensuring public safety must outrank any alleged breach of privacy.

The court was told more than 50 people who lost their lives could still be alive if plans to upgrade the road had not been held up.

Those circumstances were described as a “haunting reality” for the victims’ families.

The campaign body, formed after Tyrone Gaelic footballer John Rafferty, 21, was killed on the A5 in October 2022, urged appeal judges to ensure that a potentially life-saving development is not stalled.

Counsel for the Alternative A5 Alliance stressed it was not claiming their human rights should trump those of bereaved families.

Instead, he argued, it was merely a question of whether or not a time limit for construction should be imposed.

Delivering judgment today, the Lady Chief Justice allowed all grounds of appeal.

“When the DfI authorised the decision, it had sufficient information regarding the scheme and the transport sector policy pathways to ensure that it would not undermine compliance with reduction obligations under the 2022 Act,” she said.

Previous findings made on failures to comply with EIA Directive obligations and a duty to protect the landowners human rights by imposing a time limit on the project were also reversed.

According to Dame Siobhan, issues around rights to privacy and property were clearly taken into account.

The Department did carry out a detailed assessment in preparation for the scheme which was part of public consultation.

“The potential uncertainty for those affected as to whether the scheme would proceed was also properly acknowledged,” the Lady Chief Justice said.

She confirmed that the High Court was wrong to quash the decision to give the go-ahead for the scheme.

Pointing out how Mr Justice McAlinden had cited a lack of evidence in reaching his decision, she added: “This was not a wholesale demolition of the climate change justification but rather a call for greater clarity.

“We are satisfied that there is sufficient evidence which validates the decision made to proceed with the A5 Western Transport Corridor and that the DfI had complied with section 52 (of the Act).”

Derry Sinn Féin Councillor Christopher Jackson welcomed the Court of Appeal decision.

He said: “Today’s Court of Appeal decision is very welcome and marks an important milestone for the A5 Western Transport Corridor project, and I hope it will help to move this vital project forward at pace.

“For far too long, families and communities have lived with the devastating consequences of a road that is not fit for purpose. Too many lives have been lost and too many people injured on the A5.

“These families have campaigned for change through the most unimaginable grief, and today we pay tribute to their courage and determination.

“Sinn Féin remains committed to delivering the A5 and, most importantly, delivering the safer road that families and communities across the North West deserve.”

News you can trust since 1772
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice