Judgement reserved in challenge to Orange Order Drumcree march decision
A decision to allow the Orange Order’s flashpoint Drumcree march involved a legally flawed misunderstanding of the potential risk of public disorder, it has been claimed in the Court of Appeal.
Counsel for Garvaghy Road residents claimed the Parades Commission misdirected itself on police information about the possibility of any unrest around the disputed route in Portadown, Co Armagh.
Judgment was reserved in the group's bid to overturn a ruling that Orangemen have the right to walk through the mainly nationalist neighbourhood for the first time in nearly 30 years.
As a wider standoff over the march continues, Lady Chief Justice Dame Siobhan Keegan pledged to deliver a “swift” verdict.


Members of the Portadown District Lodge received permission from the Parades Commission for the return march from Drumcree Church to go ahead at 8am on Sunday, September 27.
A number of conditions were imposed, including an earlier start time and only 35 participants.
But the Garvaghy Road Residents Coalition (GRRC) mounted an emergency High Court challenge that weekend against the Commission’s determination.
During the first in three separate hearings, a judge initially imposed a temporary injunction on the march before the Court of Appeal lifted that order.


Another High Court judge then dismissed the residents’ application for a judicial review amid unprecedented scenes in the early hours of that Sunday morning.
Mr Justice Humphreys rejected claims that the Commission had unlawfully failed to take into account their human rights and took a flawed approach to assessing risk of public disorder.
However, hundreds of protesters later blocked the road to stop the march from happening.
A series of further attempts by the Orangemen to walk down the contested route were prevented by police.
Talks Northern Ireland Secretary Sir Chris Bryant held with both sides in the dispute have failed to break the deadlock.
Amid the ongoing stalemate, the GRRC returned to court today to mount a bid to overturn Mr Justice Humphreys’ ruling.
Denise Kiley KC, representing the group’s chairman Brendan Mac Cionnaith , advanced four main grounds of challenge. She claimed:
- The Commission asked the wrong question on the issue of disorder and misdirected itself in the police assessment.
- The determination did not disclose adequate reasons for the outcome reached on the most controversial issues.
- The determination represented a disproportionate interference with the residents’ rights to privacy and family life under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
- Granting permission for the parade but finding it necessary to impose restrictions was an irrational and inconsistent decision.
Ms Kiley insisted the Parades Commission got it wrong in assessing the threat of any unrest around the march.
Dame Siobhan, sitting in the appeal with Lord Justice Colton and Lady Justice McBride, was told the correct legal test was based on the potential for public disorder.
However, the Commission allegedly misdirected itself on the police assessment and did not accurately represent information from the PSNI in its determination.
Despite intelligence identifying nothing to suggest any unrest was being planned, senior officers were said to have been actively planning for a range of scenarios, from peaceful to violence, which could result from the parading application.
“What the Parades Commission was doing was going beyond rehearsing what the police said, and coming to its own assessment,” Ms Kiley said.
“They have taken what the police said ‘we have no specific information’, and they have substituted that as their assessment.”
She claimed the determining body failed to reflect that it was a more nuanced and unclear intelligence assessment where police were preparing for all possible eventualities.
“The Commission must properly understand what it is being told,” she insisted.
The determination, announced two days before the planned march, imposed a number of conditions, including an earlier start time and less than the 60 participants requested by Portadown District Lodge.
The ban on Orangemen marching along the route as part of their annual July parade back from a church service has remained in place since 1998.
It became a major flashpoint issue at the time, with disorder and loyalist violence breaking out across parts of Northern Ireland.
In August, the Commission conceded a procedural error in how it dealt with the Orange Order’s application for its annual parade.
But the GRRC claimed its decision not to maintain the same restrictions on Portadown District’s renewed application was unlawful and procedurally unfair.
Reasoning provided in the determination were demonstrably inadequate, internally inconsistent and failed to grapple with key issues, the court heard.
“It was crying out for an explanation, restrictions have been imposed since 1998,” Ms Kiley submitted.
“A decision has been consistently made on one basis for 28 years.
“There is no acknowledgement of the question, never mind any answer - why has this changed and why now?”
Ms Kiley insisted it was not crucial for the Orange Order to go onto the Garvaghy Road on the return leg of their march.
If it is not necessary then the interference with the residents’ Article 8 rights cannot be sustained, she contended.
In a further ground of challenge, judges were told the residents’ Article 8 privacy rights were ignored in the balance against the Orange Order’s competing Article 11 right to freedom of assembly.
Tony McGleenan KC, for the Parades Commission, described claims of a legal misdirection on the issue of disorder as misplaced.
He cautioned against “cherrypicking” isolated sections within the 31-paragraph determination at the centre of the case.
The Commission was briefed by police and faithfully reflected the assessment there was no information about any risk of violence, the court heard.
“There is no legal error here, they have identified (the issue of potential disorder) and they have examined it,” counsel said.
“This is an expert judgment by the body set up by Parliament to make these evaluations.”
Rejecting allegations about a failure to explain the change in its stance on the march, he stressed the differences in the numbers of participants, musical accompaniment, flags and emblems.
The early morning start and anticipated 14 minutes it would take to complete the march were also highlighted.
“The memory of what happened in the 1990s relates to something categorically different,” Mr McGleenan said.
The three appeal judges were also told of the state’s obligation to respect the Orange Order’s Article 11 rights to freedom of assembly and association.
“You cannot find fault with the Commission’s analysis of the Convention,” he maintained.
“The thread running through this case is there has been a legal error, that it hasn’t understood disorder correctly.
“But the fact there is disagreement with a decision in no way leads to irrationality.
“You have no basis to find a legal error with it.”
Counsel representing one of the local Orangemen, Richard McConkey KC, urged the court to dismiss the appeal.
Mr McConkey added his client has abided by the Commission’s determinations and would respect the ultimate outcome of the legal action.
Reserving judgment following closing submissions, the Lady Chief Justice said: “Hopefully we will be able to give (our decision) within a swift enough time frame.”