Reliability and repair costs - Derry Motoring with Jim McCauley
The average car on UK roads is now close to 10 years old – the oldest figure recorded, according to a new analysis of the national car parc. ‘Warrantywise’ which offers extended warranties on older vehicles, has used its market-leading Reliability Index to reveal the top ten most reliable used cars aged between 8 and 12 years old.
The latest analysis of the data shows that the Toyota Yaris leads with an outstanding score of 93.6 out of 100, while its highest recorded repair charge of £2,312 demonstrates a significantly lower cost risk compared to many alternatives – highlighting why it consistently ranks as both dependable and budget-friendly for long-term ownership.
By contrast, the Mitsubishi Outlander, while achieving a strong overall score of 85.9 out of 100 and placing fifth in the top ten, recorded the highest single repair cost within this group at £9,531. This may in part be due to the fact that the brand withdrew from the UK and European markets in 2020 as a major cost saving exercise.
However, it has announced its return in 2026. These findings show that while certain cars are less likely to break down, when major faults do occur, the repair costs can be significant – highlighting the importance of understanding both reliability and cost risk for owners of ageing vehicles.


The data comes at a time when findings from the RAC Foundation confirm that at the end of 2024, the average UK car was nine years and ten months old, highlighting a clear trend of motorists holding on to vehicles for longer. According to ‘Warrantywise’, rising living costs, supply chain challenges in the new car market, and shifting motoring regulations have all contributed to this change, with many drivers delaying new purchases in favour of keeping older cars on the road.
While this may save money on upfront replacement costs, it places far greater emphasis on reliability – making the findings of the Reliability Index more relevant than ever for motorists.
Considering cars in the 8-12 year old bracket, the Toyota Yaris headed the findings with a reliability score of 93.6, just ahead of the Honda Civic in second place with a score of 93.0. Japanese models dominated the top six places before European manufacturers featured. The Honda CR-V sat in third place behind the Civic with an 89.0 score followed by the Suzuki Swift, Mitsubishi Outlander and Toyota Aygo with respective scores of 86.5, 85.9 and 85.5.
However, the reliability scores didn’t mean cheaper repair costs. The sixth placed Toyota Aygo recorded the lowest average repair cost of £399, compared to those in the top five places where average repair costs varies from £651 for the Toyota Yaris to £1,201 for the Mitsubishi Outlander. The Mitsubishi also recorded the single highest repair cost at £9,531 compared to the Toyota Aygo at £1,297. Completing the Top Ten of the most reliable cars in this age group were the SEAT Ibiza, Ford Mondeo and Renault Clio with the Ford Ka, Citroen C1 and MINI Hatchback all tying for tenth position with a reliability count of 79.6.