Toyota dominance in reliability survey - Derry Motoring with Jim Mc Cauley
Toyota has reaffirmed its reputation as a quality manufacturer, taking four places in the Top Ten of the latest annual survey by Warrantywise. The company provides extended warranty cover for used cars and the Reliability Index is an indicator of repair frequency and costs. Topping results is the Toyota Yaris which secured its position through consistent, measurable performance, demonstrating the kind of long-term reliability that used car buyers depend on.
The extensive database spans a three-year period, and each model must have a minimum of 250 vehicles on plan to qualify for inclusion in the dataset. The Top Ten highlights the ten most reliable used vehicles to help buyers when choosing their next used car.
Toyota’s wider performance in this year’s Index is, once again, notable. With four models in the Top Ten, the Japanese manufacturer is the only brand to place more than two cars in the table, reinforcing its longstanding reputation for dependable engineering. The Toyota Aygo places third with a score of 83.8/100, while the larger Toyota RAV4 and Toyota Hilux secure fourth and sixth place with scores of 79.9/100 and 78.4/100, respectively. This breadth of performance highlights how a single manufacturer can perform consistently well across very different vehicle types.
However, the data also shows that even the top scorers are not immune to costly faults. Across the Toyota models in the Top Ten, both electrical systems and clutch-related issues feature as the most registered repair areas, with repair costs varying significantly, ranging from £1,587.60 as the most expensive repair request for the Toyota Aygo to £6,503.57 for the Hilux.


Alongside Toyota’s strong showing, the rankings also highlight the continued reliability of compact city cars. In second place, the Kia Picanto makes a strong case for itself as one of the most cost-effective cars in the Top Ten. With an average repair request of just £403.49 – the lowest of any model in the table – the Picanto proves that urban superminis can be serious long-term propositions. Scoring 86.8/100, it sits comfortably between the dominant Yaris and the rest of the field, combining low running costs with genuine, data-backed reliability.
The Peugeot 108 takes fifth place with its score of 78.9/100, while the Citroën C1 and Suzuki Vitara share seventh place with scores of 78.0/100. These results reinforce the strong reliability performance often seen among smaller vehicles despite their accessible price point.
The results reflect a broader trend within the used car market, where smaller, simpler vehicles often deliver dependable long-term ownership. With lower complexity and widely available car parts, many of these models can continue to perform reliably well into later stages of their lifecycle. The full Top Ten further includes the Kia Ceed and the Suzuki Swift, which secure the final positions in the table with scores of 77.5/100.
At the other extreme, large SUVs and executive saloons are the vehicle categories most heavily represented among the lowest-scoring models. The lowest score in this year’s data was recorded by the Land Rover Discovery (17.2/100), compared with the highest-ranking Toyota Yaris (89.2/100).
This comes at a time when the UK car parc continues to expand and age. In 2025, the total number of cars on UK roads climbed to 36,676,185 – an increase of more than half a million.